Just a quick commentary on the battles going on here as I’m revising the top 20. First off, It’s an all-out war between For a Few Dollars More and Once Upon a Time in the West. Those two have swapped places at least four times! Also, as people adjust their lists, Keoma and Run, Man, Run are losing ground fast with Cemetery without Crosses and a couple Sartana flicks creeping in for the ambush.
May the best gun win!
1—THE GOOD,THE BAD AND THE UGLY
2—FOR A FEW DOLLARS MORE
3—THE GREAT SILENCE
4—THE COMPANEROS
5—A BULLET FOR THE GENERAL
6—CEMETERY WITHOUT CROSSES
7—TWICE A JUDAS
8—A PROFESSIONAL GUN
9—DJANGO KILL
10–VENGEANCE
11–IF YOU MEET SARTANA PRAY FOR YOUR DEATH
12–I AM SARTANA—THE GRAVEDIGGER
13–ACE HIGH
14—TODAY IT’S YOU TOMORROW,IT,S YOU
15—DJANGO
16— A FISTFUL OF DOLLARS
17–DJANGO THE BASTARD
18–FOR A COFFIN FULL OF DOLLARS
19–ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST
20–ROUGH JUSTICE
ouatitw on place 19?
let’s go outside and settle this, gringo!
And worse than “Today it’s me, tomorrow it’s you”, “Django the Bastard” and “Ace High”. Wooohhha. This cannot be true.
Any Gun Can Play and the Garko Sartana’s are having a surprizingly poor showing.
Any Gun can play is in my opinions so bad, because Anthony Steffen is so weak. Without him it would have worked much better…
I seem to be a little late, but here is my top twenty:
it’s never too late.
our ranger is updating his list caluclation every 10 new lists.
nice list, i think you’re the only one with Duck you sucker on top. i was actually thinking of dropping it out of my list 
and i hate you now for having OUATITW at 9
but i am just being funny
Yes, I had never really attempted to rank them before, and was suprised myself at the result. Numbers one and two were the only ones that came easy for me. Such epic peices of art.
Yes!!! It’s so nice to see some love for Four of the Apocalypse! It’s such an unconventional western and so often overlooked. Good call Ginger Man!
There’s no Anthony Steffen in Any gun can play. It’s George Hilton film.
-but I agree, it’s not top20 film.
Hi, everybody!
Here is my personal top 20 SW
Of course, it was not easy… You have to make delicate choices!
Comment:
The first time I saw a SW, I was seven… and it was OUATITW… Like Obelix, I felt in the magic SW potion when I was a child
Sorry for the Sartana’s Fans, I’ve never seen one of the movies :’(. But they are in my want-list…
Yes, I like “The 3 Sergio”, Castellari and Tessari… But movies like"Blindman", “Django Kill…”, “Matalo” or the Fulci’s SW are very originals and unique in the “cult SW story”…
Here’s my Spaghetti Western Top 20 :
It’s not easy to put together a top 20 list !!! There’s a bunch of SW I like a lot also !!!
[attachment older than 600 days, deleted by admin]
[quote=“Bill san Antonio, post:151, topic:190”]There’s no Anthony Steffen in Any gun can play. It’s George Hilton film.
-but I agree, it’s not top20 film.[/quote]
Oh, my mistake. I thought of “No room to die”. I don’t know why “Any gun can play” came to my mind. I’m sorry…
When will voting close on this? I’d like to re watch a couple before I vote, and may sneak a new SW or two in as well. Seems like a good system.
This thing will never close. Cause the Raner updates this every ten new lists. And i believe the forum is growing and so it’ll never stop
Yes we will update the list everytime 10 new members post their list. maybe every 20 when it is more popular.
I will post the list on the main page next week, when we’ve reached a straight number of inputs
mh ,we should search for a VotingMachine ,so that everyone who visit the SWDB can vote his Favourite SW…
it’s just hard to include that into the wiki software, but i’ll see what i can do.
with over 500 films this is a bit hard though
Hey Sebastian,
There’s only been 5 new lists since the last post, but just in case you wanted to put something up, here’s the latest update:
[b]20. Run, Man, Run (29 points)
19. Cemetery without Crosses (30 points)
18. Keoma (31 points)
17. Mannaja (32 points)
16. Sabata (39 points)
15. Django, Kill… If You Live, Shoot! (45 points)
14. My Name is Nobody (48 points)
13. Face to Face (68 points)
12. A Fistful of Dynamite/Duck, You Sucker! (72 points)
11. (TIE) A Bullet for the General (79 points)
10. (TIE) The Mercenary (79 points)
09. Death Rides a Horse (101 points)
08. Companeros (104 points)
07. Django (150 points)
06. The Big Gundown (153 points)
05. (TIE) A Fistful of Dollars (227 points)
04. (TIE) The Great Silence (227 points)
03. Once Upon a Time in the West (336 points)
02. For a Few Dollars More (346 points)