Vote for Our Official Top 20


(JONAH HEX) #1

NOT SURE how YOU WANT TO DO THIS SEBASTIAN ,IF YOU HAVE ANOTHER WAY ILL BE HAPPY TO RELIST MY PICKS ON YOUR POST.I figure we list our top 12 absolute must own films,then when you feel voting is closed present a top 20,or whatever.heres my list -once upon a time in the west -the good the bad and the ugly. -the great silence. -for a few dollars more- the big gundown. -fistful of dollars. - the mercenary sabata. -compeneros. -fistful of dynamite. -death rides a horse. -light the fuse…sartana is coming…EVERYBODY VOTE!!! :slight_smile:


List YOUR Top Favorite Spaghetti Westerns
(Sebastian) #2

i will add a poll to this topic as soon as we have 20 nominees we can AGREE on

of your 12 nominees i kinda am not sure about “light the fuse”… but i haven’t seen that one yet.

i’d definitely add Face to Face and Run man Run, as well as “and god said to cain”, “god forgives, we don’t”, definitely “cemetery without crosses”, then of course “Django”, “Keoma” and “Il Mercenario” and “companeros”.

and there might be more we should mention. so in the end we will have to leave away a whole bunch but we need to reach a consensus on 20 top-notch films for the final voting.

i’ll announce this topic on the main page now as well


(Sebastian) #3

what about these:

  • the grand duel (it’s on tv here tonight, i’m gonna tape it, never seen it)
  • django - prepare the coffin (aka viva django)
  • forgotten pistolero
  • texas, adios
  • massacre time
  • the specialists

remember we dont wanna nominate our favorites here, let’s consider the best, and then vote for our favorites among THOSE


(cigar joe) #4
  1. OUTITW
  2. GBU
  3. FAFDM
  4. The Mercenary
  5. The Great Silence
  6. AFOD
  7. The Big Gundown
  8. Death Rides A Horse
  9. Companero’s
  10. Run Man Run
  11. A Bullet For The General
  12. DYS

(Yocke) #5

In no particular order:

A Fistful of Dollars
For a Few Dollars More
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
Once Upon a Time in the West
The Big Gundown
Run, Man, Run
Death Rides a Horse
Day of Anger
Mannaja
The Great Silence


(Franco Cleef) #6

My two cents:

  1. OUATITW
  2. GBU
  3. FAFDM
  4. FOD
  5. BIG GUNDOWN
    6.THE GREAT SILENCE
    7.DEATH RIDES A HORSE
    8.DJANGO
    9.LIGHT THE FUSE…SARTANA IS COMING!
  6. BLINDMAN
  7. DAY OF ANGER
  8. $10000 BLOOD MONEY
  9. DUCK YOU SUCKER
  10. IF YOU MEET SARTANA PRAY FOR YOUR DEATH
  11. THE MERCENARY
  12. COMPANEROS
  13. RUN MAN RUN
  14. I WANT HIM DEAD
  15. CUTTHROATS NINE
  16. THE SILENT STRANGER

(Martin N) #7

01 - The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
02 - Once Upon a Time in the West
03 - For a Few Dollars More
04 - The Great Silence
05 - A Bullet for the General
06 - A Fistful of Dollars
07 - Django
08 - Death Rides a Horse
09 - Companeros
10 - Tepepa
11 - Face to Face
12 - Blindman

Edited to add Face to Face! Can’t believe I forgot it.

12 is too tight


(EL CHUNCHO) #8

In addition to the mentioned above I’d like to suggest:

Navajo Joe, Matalo, Il Nero, Escondido, If you meet Sartana-pray for your death, No room to die, Requiescant, I crudeli, Mille dollari sul nero,…


(Wolf) #9

My top 12:

  1. Once upon a time in the west
  2. The good, the bad and the ugly
  3. My name is nobody
  4. For a few dollars more
  5. For a fistful of dollars
  6. Django
  7. The Great Silence
  8. Trinity is still my name
  9. They call me Trinity
  10. A bullet for the General
  11. Day of anger
  12. The grand duel

(Sebastian) #10

not sure about those Trinity movies… hm… I kinda doubt they are up there with the other 18 greatest of all…

but I guess all in all we pretty much agree on about 10 to 15 already…


(Musket) #11

my favourite 12
1.the Good,the Bad and the Ugly
2.Once upon a time in the West
3.the great Silence(il grande silenzio)
4.Django
5.For a fistfull of dollars
6.il mercenario
7.For a few dollars more
8.vamos a matar companeros
9.death rides a horse
10.Big Gundown
11.Face to Face
12.My name is Nobody

of ,course there a few more SW but I think thats my favourite 12 :wink:


(Lode) #12

No Trinity’s but what about Bandidos?


(Bill san Antonio) #13
  1. Once upon a time in the west
  2. The great silence
  3. For a Few Dollars More
  4. Face to Face
  5. The Good, the bad and the ugly
  6. Cemetary without crosses
  7. Django
  8. Keoma
  9. My name is Nobody
  10. Death rides a horse
  11. Big gundown
  12. Return of Ringo

(Guerrilla) #14

1 - The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
2 - Once Upon a Time in the West
3 - For a Few Dollars More
4 - A Fistful of Dollars
5 - A Bullet for the General
6 - Companeros
7 - Django
8 - The Big Gundown
9 - Run,Man,Run
10 - Tepepa
11 - Face to Face


(Malo) #15

This is off the top of my head…so forgive me if I forget something…

  1. The Good, The Bad & The Ugly
  2. Once Upon A Time in The West
  3. For a Few Dollars More
  4. Fistful of Dollars
  5. Day of Anger
  6. The Great Silence
  7. The Big Gundown
  8. Sabata
  9. Death Rides a Horse
  10. Django
  11. Sartana (original)
  12. My Name is Nobody

I guess the only differences for me would be Sabata and Sartana, which I don’t think have been suggested…I think Sabata should definitely be in the top 20 somewhere.


(JONAH HEX) #16

LOOKS LIKE THE TOP TEN IS GOING TO BE EASY,THE INTERESTING CHOICES WILL BE THE LOWER PICKS ;D


(Sebastian) #17

yeah that’s what I think, too.


(Cian) #18

Oh dear. I find it impossible to narrow down my favourites to 12. Here’s a list at random:

  1. The Great Silence
  2. The Big Gundown
  3. The Good, the Bad & the Ugly
  4. For a Few Dollars More
  5. If You Meet Sartana, Pray For Your Death
  6. Fistful of Dynamite
  7. Light the Fuse, Sartana is Coming
  8. Run Man Run
  9. The Mercenary
  10. Sabata
  11. Keoma (despite the singing!)
  12. Once Upon a Time in the West

I could name another 10 to 12 also ran’s that belong up there too ( Django, Companero’s etc ) but the axe has to fall somewhere…


(Lanky gunman) #19

hello,difficult choice…
here is my list

01 The good the bad and the ugly
02 The great Silence
03 For a few Dollars More
04 Django
05 Once upon a time in the West
06 A fistfull of Dollars
07 Bandidos
08 Keoma (with the singing!!!)
09 The big gundown
10 Companeros
11 Cemetery without crosses
12 Mannaya


(veda) #20

I really don’t think this is the right way to do the voting.
Lets say that we could agree on the 20 nominees. (which I personally think is impossible)
What do we do then? A poll? Somewhere else in this forum I read that there would be 5 votes per member.

(20 members (with 5 votes each) the results would probably look something like this)

#1 20 votes
#2 20 votes
#3 19 votes
#4 18 votes
#5 15 votes
#6 2 votes
#7 1 votes
#8 1 votes
#9 1 votes
#10 1 votes
#11 1 votes
#12 1 votes
#13 0 votes
#14 0 votes

#20 0 votes

Not very informative or interesting and this wouldn’t be much different even with 100 members.

I think that the result should be calculated from each member’s personal top#12.