Just thought I’d update my unofficial list after Firefox came in:
[b]
20. Django, Kill… If You Live, Shoot! (26 points)
19. Day of Anger (28 points)
18. Run, Man, Run (29 points)
17. Keoma (30 points)
16. Sabata (31 points)
15. Mannaja (32 points)
14. A Fistful of Dynamite/Duck, You Sucker! (35 points)
13. My Name is Nobody (43 points)
12. (TIE) A Bullet for the General (56 points)
11. (TIE) The Mercenary (56 points)
10. Face to Face (57 points)
09. Companeros (59 points)
08. Death Rides a Horse (82 points)
07. Django (114 points)
06. The Big Gundown (118 points)
05. A Fistful of Dollars (171 points)
04. The Great Silence (189 points)
03. For a Few Dollars More (251 points)
02. Once Upon a Time in the West (254 points)
The Good, the Bad & the Ugly (287 points)[/b]
At this point my method is on the verge of becoming obsolete. That is, anyone who votes from now on can drastically alter the placements (Example: If someone puts Django Kill! at #1 on their list, it’ll hop up 6 spots on this one).
well nevertheless. maybe only update your list everytime 10 new people post a list. i’ll send a mass message around to encourage those to post their list who haven’t yet
[quote=“volonte, post:123, topic:190”]Not in order
TGTBATU
Duck you, Sucker!
FAFDM
OUATITW
Compañeros
The great silence
The mercenary
The Big gundown
10 000 dollari per un masacro
Death rides a horse
A Bullet for the general
Run man run[/quote]
can you try an order? to make it easier for samuryan, our god of mathematicians?
OK- I try to make my personal ranking- not an easy thing:
The good, the bad and the ugly
Bullet for the general
For a few dollars more
A fistful of dollars
Once upon a time in the west
The Mercenary
Death rides a horse
Django
The great silence
10.The big gundown
11.10.000 Dollar for a massacre
12.Matalo
13.Navajo Joe
14.Blindman
15.Moment to kill
16.And god said to cain
17.Cemetary without crosses
18.Kill and pray
19.Fighting fists of Shanghai Joe
20.Long days of vengeance
21.Forgotten pistolero
22.Keoma
23.Companeros
24.Mannaja
25.Indio Black
26.Sabata
27.Face to face
28.A Stranger in town
29.The hellbenders
30.Light the fuse…Sartana is comming
Realy pretty difficult- the list is my taste of the last month.
Perhaps we should expand the list to a top 30 instead?
There are wonderful films outside of the current top 20, Matalo! for instance, and it’s a shame if they wouldn’t get proper attention to fans and newcomers.
[quote=“Silvanito, post:127, topic:190”]Perhaps we should expand the list to a top 30 instead?
There are wonderful films outside of the current top 20, Matalo! for instance, and it’s a shame if they wouldn’t get proper attention to fans and newcomers.[/quote]
then put it into your list
I think 20 is enough, I mean, for a BEST of essential westerns. We can also publish that list and then include another 20 or so “runners up” for those interested. I think that would be a good idea
I submitted my top 20 a long time ago but they were in no particular order. So her ethey are again, in order:
1 Good, Bad & the Ugly
2 Big Gundown
3 If You Meet Sartana, Pray for Your Death
4 For a Few Dollars More
5 Fistful of Dynamite
6 Cemetery Without Crosses
7 The Mercenary aka Professional Gun
8 Once Upon a Time in the West
9 Fistful of Dollars
10 Light the Fuse, Sartana is Coming
11 Sabata
12 Keoma
13 Adios Sabata
14 Run Man Run
15 Great Silence
16 Companeros
17 Django
18 Death Rides a Horse
19 Bullet for the General
20 My Name is Nobody
I think I should expand my previous top12 to top20:
1.Once upon time in the west
2.The great silence
3.for a few dollars more
4.Face to Face
5.Cemetary without crosses
6.Good the bad and the ugly
7.Django
8.Keoma
9.My name is Nobody
10.Death rides a horse
11.Big gundown
12.Return of Ringo
13.Duck you sucker!
14.Companeros
15.Bandidos
16.Fistfull of dollars
17.God forgives I don’t
18.Viva Django
19.Pistol for Ringo
20.And God said to Cain
ok my top 20 again:
1.Once upon a time in the West
2.The Good,the Bad and the Ugly
3.The great Silence
4.Face to Face
5.For a few Dollars more
6.Fistful of Dollars
7.The Mercenary
8.La reisa dei Conti
9.Django
10.Companeros
11.Death rides a horse
12.Duck u sucker/Fistfull of Dynamite
13.God forgives ,I don`t
14.My name is Nobody
15.Keoma
16.Sabata
17.Preparati la bara!
18.Run man run
19.Navajo Joe
20.Massacre Time
Maybe some are wondering about my list,i havent seen so many SW
Nice to see some new faces at the campfire. After a couple of corrections and some slight alterations (following a few revised lists), here’s the updated body count:
(And just so’s ya know… It’s pretty easy to move things around. Please just let me know in the future if you’ve already posted a list and are just reorganizing it - don’t want to count anybody twice!)
[b]20. Run, Man, Run (25 points)
19. Day of Anger (28 points)
18. (TIE) Django, Kill… If You Live, Shoot! (29 points)
17. (TIE) Keoma (29 points)
16. Mannaja (32 points)
15. Sabata (39 points)
14. My Name is Nobody (48 points)
13. A Fistful of Dynamite/Duck, You Sucker! (54 points)
12. Face to Face (63 points)
11. A Bullet for the General (66 points)
10. The Mercenary (73 points)
09. Companeros (85 points)
08. Death Rides a Horse (101 points)
07. Django (123 points)
06. The Big Gundown (139 points)
05. The Great Silence (192 points)
04. A Fistful of Dollars (203 points)
03. Once Upon a Time in the West (297 points)
02. For a Few Dollars More (298 points)
The Good, the Bad & the Ugly (343 points)[/b]
And hot on their tails:
Cemetery without Crosses (24 points)
If You Meet Sartana, Pray for Your Death (23 points)
Light the Fuse… Sartana is Coming (15 points)
Everybody has such great lists! I’ve dropped about as much gold as my saddle can carry trying to track down some of the titles you guys are throwing around. (And by the way Sebastian… I think I saw a WANTED poster with your mug on it down at the saloon.)
