Vote for Our Official Top 20

Town Hall
3361

I have seen 3 versions. On Amazon Germany there is a 90 minute version, an English grey market version with 93 minutes and an Italian version also with 93 minutes. There are scenes in all 3 versions that are not included in the others. That’s why the Blu-ray from Filmart, which has been announced 10 years ago, is long overdue and hopefully uncut. This SW is unique, bizarre, ludicrous, completely crazy, extraordinary, over the top, strange, cruel, enigmatic, silent, strongly symbolic, dark and rugged.
The review on swdb is very good!
https://www.spaghetti-western.net/index.php/Hate_Is_My_God_review

Watch it, you won’t regret!

1 Like
3362

I have updated my ranking and expanded it to a Top 50.

  1. The Good, The Bad & The Ugly
  2. The Great Silence
  3. For A Few Dollars More
  4. Face To Face
  5. For A Fistful Of Dollars
  6. A Bullet For The General
  7. The Big Gundown
  8. Massacre Time
  9. Cemetery Without Crosses
  10. California
  11. $10.000 Blood Money
  12. Django
  13. The Ruthless Four
  14. Run, Man, Run
  15. I Want Him Dead
  16. 100.000 Dollars For A Killing
  17. Blindman
  18. The Dirty Outlaws
  19. A Minute To Pray, A Second To Die
  20. Death Rides A Horse
  21. The Grand Duel
  22. My Name Is Nobody
  23. God Forgives… I Don’t!
  24. The Mercenary
  25. The Stranger Returns
  26. Duck, You Sucker!
  27. Django Kill…If You Live, Shoot!
  28. Day Of Anger
  29. Cut Throats Nine
  30. Vengeance
  31. Bandidos
  32. They Call Me Halleluja
  33. And God Said To Cain
  34. Night Of The Serpent
  35. A Bullet For Sandoval
  36. Dead Men Ride
  37. Mannaja
  38. Johnny Hamlet
  39. I Am Sartana, Your Angel Of Death
  40. Tepepa
  41. Shoot, Gringo…Shoot!
  42. Keoma
  43. John The Bastard
  44. Long Live… Your Death
  45. Il Nero
  46. Navajo Joe
  47. Light The Fuse… Sartana Is Coming
  48. Texas Adios
  49. Django The Bastard
  50. Kill And Pray
4 Likes
3363

Just out of curiosity, They Call Him Cemetery was in your old list # 11, and is now not even in your Top 50.
You forgot that one, or is it just one you don’t like that much anymore?

3364

To be honest, last time I confused They Call Him Cemetery with They Call Me Hallelujah :sweat_smile:

3365

Ha ha, that can happen in the Carnimeoverse …

Hmm, it’s a very underrated film, often quite stylish, a bit silly in places of course, as compensation for the mix-up you should rewatch it immediately and put in your top 10 for at least 2 years … :wink:

3366

I rewatched both films again and really like them both. Spirito Santo is also fun, but Camposanto and Spirito just missed the top 50. However, the transition between places 20-75 is often fluid in terms of ratings. I think that as a fan of the genre, you should have at least 100 spaghetti westerns in your collection.

3367

The Carnimeos are all fun to watch, up to the point when the comedy took over, mainly the last 2 with Hilton as Tresette. I rewatched Camposanto too a few weeks ago, and Spiritio Santo and the 4 Sartanas also not so long ago.
For me the 1st Halleluja is his best, actually I did not care for it the first time I watched it, but since then it got better and better and better, actually Halleluja will make my next top 20 …
Where will that end? Will Halleluja one day kick Leone from the throne? Is it a god send film in the end? If so, why does the world ignore its blessings? And what has Dumb Trump to do with it?
MHGA …

1 Like
3368

Amazing or strange that the movie, once upon a time in the west, isn’t in the top ten

of this list.

3369

Some great lists.

Decided to finally create my own top 20. It’s tougher than I anticipated. Also I can’t remember all of the ones I’ve watched in the past few years, so I think re-watches will be required.

1 Like
3370

Just do it, you can change it by posting a revised one at any time after re-watching this or that one.

2 Likes
3371

Yes, objectively speaking, it’s certainly a more than good film. Personally, I simply prefer other Spaghetti Westerns. In Once Upon a Time in the West, everything seems to happen at half speed. Of course, that’s a stylistic device, and it’s precisely because of it that some scenes are unforgettable, especially in conjunction with the great visuals and the first-class music. But I simply enjoy watching many other films in this genre much more.

2 Likes
3372

My thoughts, precisely. Here’s mine, FWIW:

  1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  2. The Great Silence
  3. The Big Gundown
  4. And God Said to Cain
  5. Duck, You Sucker!
  6. A Fistful of Dollars
  7. Tepepa
  8. Django
  9. Death Rides a Horse
  10. Cemetery Without Crosses
  11. Day of Anger
  12. Django, Prepare a Coffin
  13. The Return of Ringo
  14. A Bullet fo the General
  15. A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
  16. Shoot the Living and Pray for the Dead
  17. Run, Man, Run
  18. Navajo Joe
  19. The Mercenary
  20. The Hellbenders
4 Likes
3373

Great list! Except for Return of Ringo. I don’t understand why this movie is so popular :grimacing:

2 Likes
3374

He’s my favourite Beatle.

3 Likes
3375

Always nice to read these lists. I decided to update mine too with the help of pairwise comparison.

  1. Ace High
  2. Django the Bastard
  3. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  4. For a Few Dollars More
  5. Death Rides a Horse
  6. Once Upon a Time in the West
  7. Dead Men Don’t Count
  8. The Great Silence
  9. My Name is Nobody
  10. The Price of Power
  11. Django… Prepare a Coffin
  12. Johnny Hamlet
  13. The Forgotten Pistolero
  14. Keoma
  15. Ringo and His Golden Pistol
  16. Garringo
  17. Ben and Charlie
  18. Tequila Joe
  19. Massacre Time
  20. Wrath of God
4 Likes
3376

I needed to update my Top 20 SW’s of All Time list. They are as follows:

  1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966) S. Leone
  2. Once Upon a Time In the West (1968) S. Leone
  3. The Great Silence (1968) S. Corbucci
  4. The Big Gundown (1967) S. Sollima
  5. A Fistful of Dollars (1964) S. Leone
  6. Django (1966) S. Corbucci
  7. Death Rides a Horse (1967) G. Petroni
  8. Duck You Sucker! (1971) S. Leone
  9. A Bullet for the General (1966) D. Damiani
  10. For a Few Dollars More (1965) S. Leone
  11. Cemetery Without Crosses (1968) R. Hussein
  12. Keoma (1976) E.G. Castellari
  13. The Return of Ringo (1965) D. Tessari
  14. Navajo Joe (1966) S. Corbucci
  15. My Name Is Nobody (1973) S. Leone/T. Valerii
  16. Django Kill…If You Live, Shoot! (1967) G. Questi
  17. The Forgotten Pistolero (1969) F. Baldi
  18. Mannaja (1977) S. Martino
  19. Django the Bastard (1969) S. Garrone
  20. Bandidos (1967) M. Dallamano
5 Likes
3377

Danke @Stanton für den Hinweis meine TOP 20 Spaghetti Western hier zu veröffentlichen:

  1. Zwei glorreiche Halunken (Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo)

  2. Spiel mir das Lied vom Tod (C’era una volta il West)

  3. Leichen pflastern seinen Weg (Il grande silenzio)

  4. Für eine Handvoll Dollar (Per un pugno di dollari)

  5. Django (Django)

  6. Für ein paar Dollar mehr (Per qualche dollaro in più)

  7. Der Tod ritt dienstags (I giorni dell’ira)

  8. Das Gold von Sam Cooper (Ognuno per sé)

  9. Friedhof ohne Kreuze (Une corde, un colt…)

  10. Zwei Himmelhunde im Wilden Westen (Ben & Charlie)

  11. Mögen sie in Frieden ruhen (Requiescant)

  12. Heute ich - morgen du (Oggi a me… domani a te!)

  13. Die rechte und die linke Hand des Teufels (Lo chiamavano Trinità)

  14. Todesmelodie (Giù la testa)

  15. Django sein Gesangbuch war der Colt (Le colt cantarono la morte e fu… tempo di massacro)

  16. Mercenario - Der Gefürchtete (Il mercenario)

  17. Blindman - Der Volkstrecker (Blindman)

  18. Amigos (…E per tetto un cielo di stelle)

  19. Der Mann aus Virginia (California)

  20. Yankee (Yankee)

3 Likes
3378

Updated Top 20

  1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  2. Once Upon a Time in the West
  3. Day of Anger
  4. The Big Gundown
  5. Keoma
  6. The Great Silence
  7. Django
  8. A Fistful of Dollars
  9. For a Few Dollars More
  10. A Cemetery Without Crosses
  11. The Price of Power (A Bullet for the President)
  12. The Return of Ringo
  13. My Name is Nobody
  14. Vamos a Matar, Companeros
  15. A Bullet for the General
  16. The Grand Duel
  17. Run, Man, Run
  18. Sabata
  19. Have a Good Funeral, My Friend… Sartana Will Pay
  20. In a Colt’s Shadow
4 Likes
3379

Updated list:

  1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  2. For a Few Dollars More
  3. Death Rides a Horse
  4. Keoma
  5. Day of Anger
  6. Shoot the Living and Pray for the Dead
  7. Blindman
  8. Big Gundown
  9. A Bullet for the General
  10. The Silent Stranger
  11. Fistful of Dollars
  12. Once Upon a Time in the West
  13. Red Sun
  14. Django
  15. Run, Man, Run
  16. Bullets Don’t Argue
  17. Kill Them All and Come Back Alone
  18. California
  19. Train for Durango
  20. The Five Man Army
3 Likes