morgan:
As for fresh air, how about a one time poll for the top 20 hardcore low budget spaghs not made by any of the three Sergios, also leaving out the other Zapats and the comedies, only the gritty stuff outside the official top 20, and using Phil’s restrictive definition of what films are eligible?
But how many films would be included in the poll?
I was wondering whether it’s possible to compile a decent, reasonably interesting list of 20 SWs without using the 210 films in the complete list shown above
Here is a first try, just for fun (the movies are listed in a random order)
Django Shoots First
morgan
July 21, 2019, 9:49pm
2874
Possible, yes. Some top-notch films in that list you put together there. Anyway, the poll I suggested above would probably have ended up pretty close to the Alternative top 20. But how about a poll for the 20 best hard core spaghs not in the Official top 20 nor in the Alternative top 20?
My nominations for such a list would be, if allowed, at least these, and probably one or two more:
Boot Hill Sonora I Want Him Dead And the Crows Will Dig Your Grave The Long Days of Vengeance Cost of Dying Challenge Of The McKennas El Bandido Malpelo Hate Is My God Death Played the Flute The Ultimate Killer Why Go on Killing? Terrible Day of the Big Gundown Vengeance for Vengeance Fury of Johnny Kid
morgan
July 21, 2019, 9:54pm
2875
Edited because of double posting.
stanton
July 22, 2019, 11:26am
2876
I suggest to discuss these matters I a new thread.
3 Likes
Update time…reshuffled the list with two new entries.
1.For a Few Dollars MoreA Minute to Pray, A Second to Die The Last Killer
2 Likes
It would be interesting to see Tarantino update his list!
Admin
September 25, 2019, 6:29pm
2880
well I will bring it up next time we meet
1 Like
tomas
November 20, 2019, 9:13pm
2882
Great, I have one or two changes in my top too caused by this year’s spagvember fest, but I’ll wait until it’s over.
runner
November 20, 2019, 9:27pm
2883
Some changes since last time. My Name Is Nobody and Dead Men Ride have advanced, and My Name Is Pecos is new on my Top 20.
1 For A Few Dollars More (Sergio Leone)
Mickey13
November 21, 2019, 12:30am
2884
Yeah, that was my original intention, but I figured my Top 20 was not likely change and went ahead. I might as well edit my post later on and since Stanton updates the ranking every now and then, it’s not that much of a big deal anyway.
tomas
November 21, 2019, 2:29pm
2885
Hmmmm, don’t be so sure, you have a bunch of Creas and Fidanis ahead of you.
1 Like
Mickey13
November 30, 2019, 11:17pm
2886
Edited the old new Top 20, everything should be all right now. Mentioning this just for the sake of clarity.
tomas
December 1, 2019, 12:02am
2887
tomas:
GBU
The Great Silence
The Silent Stranger
The Specialists
Companeros
Long Live Your Death
Ace High
The Stranger Returns
The Moment To Kill
Sonny and Jed
Boots Hill
California
Blindman
Django Kill!
Face To Face
Fistful Of Lead
The Mercenary
Drummer Of Vengeance
Keoma
Get Mean
A minor change resulted from Spagvember Fest 2019:
GBU
The Great Silence
The Silent Stranger
The Specialists
Companeros
Long Live Your Death
Ace High
The Stranger Returns
The Moment To Kill
Sonny and Jed
Boots Hill
California
Blindman
Django Kill!
Face To Face
John The Bastard Fistful Of Lead
The Mercenary
Drummer Of Vengeance
Keoma
1 Like
I’ve reached the nummer of 100 seen spags with this years fest so I feel that an update is needed.
Old List:
1.The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
New:
1 Like
stanton
January 6, 2020, 3:56pm
2889
New year, new update in the near future…
The last update was from March, and only 5 new lists, next to some altered ones, have arrived. But anyone who wants to rethink his old list can do that now. Some of the oldest members haven’t done this for many years, and we are still waiting for the one by Ennio … most likely the list to end all lists … who knows …
1 Like
stanton
January 9, 2020, 11:56am
2890
After 14 years of voting, taken from actual 178 lists, the Spag world is (despite some trumpian interference) in a good condition:
Jan 20
Jan 18
English Title
Director
Points
1
1
The Good, the Bad, the Ugly
*
Leone, Sergio
*
3509
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
2
2
Once Upon a Time in the West
*
Leone, Sergio
*
3079
3
3
For a Few Dollars More
*
Leone, Sergio
*
2965
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
4
4
The Great Silence
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
2329
5
7
The Big Gundown
*
Sollima, Sergio
*
1874
6
5
A Fistful of Dollars
*
Leone, Sergio
*
1858
7
6
Django
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
1850
8
8
The Mercenary
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
1328
9
9
Companeros
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
1180
10
10
Death Rides a Horse / Man to Man
*
Petroni, Giulio
*
1129
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
11
11
Face to Face
*
Sollima, Sergio
*
1111
12
12
Duck, You Sucker!
*
Leone, Sergio
*
1083
13
13
A Bullet for the General
*
Damiani, Damiano
*
1018
14
14
Day of Anger
*
Valerii, Tonino
*
825
15
15
Keoma
*
Castellari, Enzo G.
*
785
16
16
Cemetery Without Crosses
*
Hossein, Robert
*
749
17
17
My Name is Nobody
*
Leone, Sergio/Valerii, T.
*
655
18
18
The Return of Ringo
*
Tessari, Duccio
*
639
19
19
Django Kill…If You Live, Shoot!
*
Questi, Giulio
*
541
20
20
Run Man, Run
*
Sollima, Sergio
*
385
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
21
21
If You Meet Sartana Pray for Your Death
*
Parolini, Gianfranco
*
383
22
22
Blindman
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
339
23
23
Sabata
*
Parolini, Gianfranco
*
313
24
24
10,000 Dollars Blood Money
*
Girolami, Romolo
*
310
25
26
And God Said to Cain
*
Margheriti, Antonio
*
285
26
29
Tepepa
*
Petroni, Giulio
*
274
27
27
Navajo Joe
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
273
28
25
Mannaja / A Man Called Blade
*
Martino, Sergio
*
268
29
28
A Pistol for Ringo
*
Tessari, Duccio
*
253
30
30
Light the Fuse…Sartana is Coming
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
201
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
31
31
Massacre Time
*
Fulci, Lucio
*
198
32
32
God Forgives…I Don’t
*
Colizzi, Giuseppe
*
195
33
33
California
*
Lupo, Michele
*
189
34
36
Kill and Pray / Requiescant
*
Lizzani, Carlo
*
178
35
39
Four of the Apocalypse
*
Fulci, Lucio
*
175
36
35
Bandidos
*
Dallamano, Massimo
*
172
37
38
El Puro
*
Mulargia, Edoardo
*
169
38
37
Johnny Hamlet
*
Castellari, Enzo G.
*
166
39
41
Vengeance
*
Margheriti, Antonio
*
158
40
34
The Grand Duel
*
Santi, Giancarlo
*
154
41
40
The Forgotten Pistolero
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
138
42
44
Matalo!
*
Canevari, Cesare
*
137
43
50
Ace High / 4 for an Ave Maria
*
Colizzi, Giuseppe
*
130
44
47
The Bounty Killer
*
Martin, Eugenio
*
130
45
45
The Hellbenders
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
126
46
43
Django the Bastard
*
Garrone, Sergio
*
124
47
49
Shoot the Living and Pray for the Dead
*
Vari, Giuseppe
*
122
48
61
Arizona Colt
*
Lupo, Michele
*
114
49
51
The Ruthless Four / Each One for His Own
*
Capitani, Giorgio
*
113
50
48
The Specialists
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
109
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
51
42
Death Sentence
*
Lanfranchi, Mario
*
107
52
46
Trinity is Still My Name
*
Barboni, Enzo
*
107
53
52
Dead Men Ride
*
Florio, Aldo
*
104
54
53
I Want Him Dead
*
Bianchini, Paolo
*
103
55
54
They Call Him Cemetery
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
95
56
55
A Stranger in Town
*
Vanzi, Luigi
*
91
57
59
For 100 000 Dollars per Killing
*
Fago, Giovanni
*
90
58
58
Yankee
*
Brass, Tinto
*
89
59
67
Duel in the Eclipse / Requiem for a Gringo
*
Merino, José Luis
*
87
60
65
Cut Throats Nine
*
Marchent, Joaquin Luis Rom.
*
82
61
60
The Moment to Kill
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
80
62
56
They Call Me Trinity
*
Barboni, Enzo
*
79
63
57
A Bullet for Sandoval
*
Buchs, Julio
*
78
63
63
Johnny Yuma
*
Girolami, Romolo
*
78
65
64
Adios Sabata
*
Parolini, Gianfranco
*
77
66
71
Black Jack
*
Baldanello, Gianfranco
*
75
67
62
Django, Prepare a Coffin
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
71
68
69
The Dirty Outlaws / El desperado
*
Rossetti, Franco
*
71
69
70
Have a Good Funeral, My Friend…Sartana Will Pay
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
71
70
68
I am Sartana, Your Angel of Death
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
70
71
72
No Room to Die / A Long File of Crosses
*
Garrone, Sergio
*
70
72
76
The Price of Power
*
Valerii, Tonino
*
66
73
66
Texas Adios
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
64
74
74
Red Sun
*
Young, Terence
*
60
75
79
Today it’s Me…Tomorrow You
*
Cervi, Tonino
*
56
75
73
A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
*
Giraldi, Franco
*
56
77
78
The Silent Stranger
*
Vanzi, Luigi
*
56
78
80
Long Days of Vengeance
*
Vancini, Florestano
*
55
79
77
Cost of Dying / Taste of Death
*
Merolle, Sergio
*
53
80
75
One Silver Dollar
*
Ferroni, Giorgio
*
51
81
95
Taste of Violence
*
Hossein, Robert
*
48
82
81
One after Another
*
Nostro, Nick
*
46
83
98
Sonny and Jed
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
45
84
85
Garringo
*
Marchent, Rafael Romero
*
44
85
86
The Stranger Returns
*
Vanzi, Luigi
*
44
86
84
Long Live Your Death
*
Tessari, Duccio
*
44
87
82
A Hole in the Forehead
*
Vari, Guiseppe
*
42
87
82
Fighting Fists of Shanghai Joe
*
Caiano, Mario
*
42
89
88
Cowards Don’t Pray
*
Siciliano, Mario
*
40
90
87
Five Man Army
*
Taylor, Don
*
36
91
89
Blood at Sundown / 1 000 Dollars on the Black
*
Cardone, Alberto
*
34
92
91
Shoot, Gringo…Shoot!
*
Corbucci, Bruno
*
33
93
92
Ben and Charlie
*
Lupo, Michele
*
32
94
99
Night of the Serpent
*
Petroni, Giulio
*
31
95
94
The Last Killer
*
Vari, Giuseppe
*
29
96
105
Minnesota Clay
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
29
96
93
Boot Hill
*
Colizzi, Giuseppe
*
29
98
95
Revenge for Revenge
*
Colucci, Mario
*
28
99
90
I am Sartana, Trade Your Guns for a Coffin / A Fistful of Lead
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
27
100
104
Silver Saddle
*
Fulci, Lucio
*
27
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
101
97
They Call Me Hallelujah / Heads I Kill You, Tails You Die
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
26
102
100
The Hills Run Red / A River of Dollars
*
Lizzani, Carlo
*
26
103
102
Pistoleros
*
Caltabiano, Alfio
*
25
104
103
Viva Cangaceiro
*
Fago, Giovanni
*
24
105
113
Kill Them All and Come Back Alone
*
Castellari, Enzo G.
*
23
106
105
A Man Called Sledge
*
Morrow, Vic
*
22
107
122
A Genius, Two Partners and a Dupe / Nobody’s the Greatest
*
Damiani, Damiano
*
22
108
124
John the Bastard
*
Crispino, Armando
*
21
109
107
Hate for Hate
*
Paolella, Domenico
*
21
110
108
A Barrel Full of Dollars
*
Fidani, Demofilo
*
20
111
109
Dead Men Don’t Make Shadows
*
Fidani, Demofilo
*
20
112
111
Beyond the Law
*
Stegani Giorgio C.
*
20
113
109
Sartana Does Not Forgive
*
Balcazar, Alfonso
*
19
113
112
Apache Woman
*
Mariuzzo, Giorgio
*
19
115
119
The Fury of Johnny Kid
*
Puccini, Gianni
*
18
116
114
The Unholy Four / Chuck Mool
*
Barboni, Enzo
*
18
117
115
The Return of Sabata
*
Parolini, Gianfranco
*
18
118
116
Bullets Don’t Argue
*
Caiano, Mario
*
18
118
116
God Made Them… I Kill Them / God Forgives … His Life is Mine
*
Bianchini, Paolo
*
18
120
120
W Django
*
Mulargia, Eduardo
*
17
120
120
A Reason to Live, A Reason to Die
*
Valerii, Tonino
*
17
122
116
Drummer of Vengeance
*
Gariazzo, Mario
*
17
123
124
Life is Tough, Eh Providence?
*
Petroni, Giulio
*
16
124
126
Seven Guns for the MacGregors
*
Giraldi, Franco
*
16
124
126
Fort Yuma Gold
*
Ferroni, Giorgio
*
16
124
Killer Caliber .32
*
Brescia, Alfonso
*
16
127
128
Man, Pride, Vengeance
*
Bazzoni, Luigi
*
15
128
133
For the Taste of Killing
*
Valerii, Tonino
*
14
129
129
Death Walks in Laredo
*
Pero, Enzi
*
13
130
131
Trinity Sees Red / The Color of the Wind
*
Camus, Mario
*
12
130
139
Seven Dollars on the Red
*
Cardone, Alberto
*
12
132
135
Shotgun
*
Mauri, Roberto
*
11
133
132
Ringo from Nebraska
*
Bava, Mario
*
10
133
137
The Greatest Robbery in the West
*
Lucidi, Maurizio
*
10
133
137
A Pistol for 100 Coffins
*
Lenzi, Umberto
*
10
136
133
Train for Durango
*
Caiano, Mario
*
9
137
140
Viva Maria
*
Malle, Louis
*
7
138
141
Tequila Joe
*
Dell’Aquila, Vincenzo
*
5
139
142
Any Gun Can Play
*
Castellari, Enzo G.
*
5
139
142
Hate Thy Neighbour
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
5
139
142
And for a Roof a Sky Full of Stars
*
Petroni, Giulio
*
5
142
145
It Can Be Done, Amigo!
*
Lucidi, Maurizio
*
4
142
145
The Belle Star Story
*
Wertmüller, Lina
*
4
144
147
The Beast
*
Costa, Mario
*
3
144
147
Ringo and his Golden Pistol
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
3
1 Like
stanton
January 9, 2020, 12:19pm
2891
And in a second list some further Spaggies which got only vote. Some goodies amongst them.
Jan 20
Jan 18
English Title
Director
Pts.
146
Death Played the Flute
*
Panaccio, Angelo
*
25
147
Law of Violence
*
Crea, Gianni
*
21
148
Ringo: The Lone Rider
*
Marchent, Rafael Romero
*
19
149
Red Blood, Yellow Gold
*
Cicero, Fernando
*
19
150
Comin’ at Ya!
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
19
151
A Man Called Apocalypse Joe
*
Savona, Leopoldo
*
17
152
Hate Is My God
*
Gora,Claudio
*
17
153
Django and Sartana Are Coming… It’s the End
*
Fidani, Demofilo
*
17
154
Killer Adios
*
Zeglio, Primo
*
16
155
101
The Price of Death
*
Palli, Enzo Gicca
*
15
156
Execution
*
Paolella, Domenico
*
14
157
Two Crosses at Danger Pass
*
Marchent, Rafael Romero
*
14
158
Twice a Judas
*
Cicero, Fernando
*
14
159
No Graves on Boot Hill
*
Garrone, Sergio
*
13
160
God Does Not Pay on Saturday / Kill the Wicked
*
Boccia, Tanio
*
13
161
Gentleman Killer
*
Stegani, Giorgio
*
12
162
El Rojo
*
Savona, Leopoldo
*
12
163
Django Kills Softly
*
Pupillo, Massimo
*
11
164
Return of Halleluja
*
Carnimeo, Giuliano
*
10
165
Shango
*
Mulargia, Edoardo
*
9
166
A Coffin for the Sheriff
*
Caiano, Mario
*
9
167
A Bounty Killer for Trinity
*
Massaccesi, Aristide
*
9
168
Up the MacGregors!
*
Giraldi, Franco
*
9
169
Black Killer
*
Croccolo, Carlo
*
9
170
A Man Called Noon
*
Collinson, Peter
*
9
171
Garter Colt
*
Rocco, Gian Andrea
*
8
172
Halleluja and Sartana Strike Again
*
Siciliano, Mario
*
7
173
His Colt, Himself, His Revenge
*
Merighi, Ferdinando
*
7
174
7 Guns from Texas
*
Marchent, Joaquin Luis Rom.
*
7
175
122
Wanted
*
Ferroni, Giorgio
*
6
176
Between God, the Devil and a Winchester
*
Girolami, Marino
*
6
177
I’ll Sell My Skin Dearly
*
Fizzarotti, Ettore Maria
*
6
178
129
Boldest Job in the West
*
De La Loma, José Antonio
*
5
179
Revenge of the Resurrected
*
Marchent, Rafael Romero
*
5
180
Those Dirty Dogs
*
Rosati, Giuseppe
*
5
181
What am I Doing in the Middle of the Revolution?
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
5
182
Days of Violence
*
Brescia, Alfonso
*
5
183
Rita of the West
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
5
184
Killer Kid
*
Savona, Leopoldo
*
5
185
Ramon the Mexican
*
Pradeaux, Maurizio
*
5
186
Take a Hard Ride
*
Margheriti, Antonio
*
4
187
Born to Kill
*
Mollica, Antonio
*
4
188
Cjamango
*
Mulargia, Edoardo
*
4
189
15 Scaffolds for a Killer
*
Malasomma, Nunzio
*
4
190
Ringo, the Face of Revenge
*
Caiano, Mario
*
4
191
The Tramplers
*
Antonini, Alfredo
*
4
192
135
May God Forgive You… But I Won’t
*
Musolino, Vincenzo
*
3
193
Buddy Goes West
*
Lupo, Michele
*
3
194
Sugar Colt
*
Giraldi, Franco
*
3
195
Five Giants From Texas / Five for Revenge
*
Florio, Aldo
*
3
196
Sabata the Killer
*
Demicheli, Tulio
*
3
197
Fasthand Is Still My Name
*
Bianchi, Mario
*
3
198
God’s Gun
*
Parolini, Gianfranco
*
2
199
Sartana in the Valley of Death
*
Mauri, Roberto
*
2
200
The Stranger and the Gunfighter
*
Margheriti, Antonio
*
2
201
Quinto: Fighting Proud
*
Klimovsky, Léon
*
2
202
Trinity Plus the Clown and a Guitar
*
Antel, Franz
*
2
203
Get Mean
*
Baldi, Ferdinando
*
1
204
More Dollars for the MacGregors
*
Merino, José Luis
*
1
205
Vendetta at Dawn / Terrible Day of the Big Gundown
*
Garrone, Sergio
*
1
206
A Stranger in Paso Bravo
*
Rosso, Salvatore
*
1
207
For a Book of Dollars
*
Girolami, Renzo
*
1
208
Don’t Touch the White Woman
*
Ferreri, Marco
*
1
209
The White, the Yellow and the Black
*
Corbucci, Sergio
*
1
210
This Man Can’t Die
*
Baldanello, Gianfranco
*
1
211
Machine Gun Killers
*
Bianchini, Paolo
*
1
212
My Name is Pecos
*
Lucidi, Maurizio
*
1
1 Like
Dean
January 9, 2020, 1:52pm
2892
I’d be curious to see the updates to your personal list over the years, Stanton. As I assume you’ll just put them into the spreadsheet instead of on here.
