Vote for Our Official Top 20

Town Hall
266

yay! thanks for joining, man! thanks for posting the list!

267
  1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  2. For a Few Dollars More
  3. The Big Gundown
  4. Once Upon a Time in the West
  5. The Mercenary
  6. Django
  7. Day of Anger
  8. Compañeros
  9. Death Rides a Horse
  10. The Grand Duel
  11. A Fistful of Dollars
  12. The Great Silence
  13. Sabata
  14. Blindman
  15. Long Day of Vengeance
  16. Return of Sabata
  17. Run, Man, Run
  18. Face to Face
  19. Mannaja
  20. My Name is Nobody
268

Top Twenty List! No paticular order.

  1. A Few Dollars More
  2. Blindman
  3. A Bullet for Sandoval
  4. Mannaja
  5. Grand Duel
  6. Big Gundown
  7. Navajo Joe
  8. Django Kill
  9. Companeros
  10. Grand Silence
  11. The Good the Bad and the Ugly
  12. Sabata
  13. And God Said to Cain
  14. Price of Death
  15. Once Upon a Time in the West
  16. Texas Addios
  17. Death Rides a Horse
  18. A Fistful of Dollars
  19. Ramon the Mexican
  20. Day of Anger
269

nonono, the order is VERY important! it decides over the ranking, according to the formula we’re using to calculate it

270
  1. FOR A FEW DOLLARS MORE
  2. DJANGO
  3. DUCK YOU SUCKER
  4. ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST
  5. THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY
  6. I AM SARTANA, YOUR ANGEL OF DEATH
  7. IF YOU MEET SARTANA, PRAY FOR YOUR DEATH
  8. RUN MAN RUN
  9. FACE TO FACE
  10. MANNAJA
  11. KEOMA
  12. RED SUN
  13. ACE HIGH
  14. FORGOTTEN PISTOLERO
  15. DAY OF ANGER
  16. BLINDMAN
  17. SABATA
  18. $100.000 PER KILLING
  19. $10.000 BLOOD MONEY
  20. GREAT SILENCE
271

Hi guys !

I was in Germany a few month ago at the fleamarket of Bonn. I came across so many spag. western dvd’s !! but unfortunately for me, there were all German spoken or subtitled :’( There still a lot for me to see, but here is my top list (only good movies ;D) :

  1. The good, the bad and the ugly
  2. The grand silence
  3. For a fistfull of dollars
  4. Once upon a time in the west
  5. Face to face
  6. Day of anger
  7. For a fistful of dollars
  8. My name is nobody
  9. Django
272
  1. The Great Silence
  2. For A Few Dollars More
  3. The Good, The Bad And The Ugly
  4. Light The Fuse… Sartana Is Coming
  5. Day Of Anger
  6. The Big Gundown
  7. Once Upon A Time In The West
  8. Duck You Sucker / Fistful Of Dynamite
  9. Fistful Of Dollars
  10. Death Rides A Horse
  11. Face To Face
  12. Ace High
  13. Sabata
  14. The Specialist
  15. My Name Is Nobody
  16. The Mercenary
  17. No Room To Die
  18. Have a Good Funeral, My Friend… Sartana Will Pay
  19. Death Sentence
  20. Compañeros
273

OK my list:

  1. For a Few Dollars More
  2. Django
  3. A Fistful of Dollars
  4. The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
  5. Once Upon a time in the west
  6. The Big Gundown
  7. Run, Man, Run
  8. Texas, Adios
  9. Companeros
  10. Have a Good Funeral, Sartana will pay
  11. Light the Fuse, Sartana’s coming
  12. If you meet Sartana, Pray for your Death
  13. Sabata
  14. Bullet for a general
  15. Wanted
  16. One Silver Dollar
  17. Massacre Time
  18. Arizona Colt
  19. Day of Anger
  20. Death Rides A Horse
274

Fine, many new lists, but the lists from Yohanes, Yocke and Twiceajudas are revised lists. To avoid confusion it should be mentioned if it is a new or an altered list.

275

and some I saw weren’t 20 films…

276

01.ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST
02.THE GOOD THE BAD AND THE UGLY
03.FOR A FEW DOLLARS MORE
04.FISTFUL OF DYNAMITE
05.COMPANEROS
06.A FISTFUL OF DOLLARS
07.THE MERCENARY
08.THE BIG GUNDOWN
09.THE GREAT SILENCE
10.KEOMA
11.DJANGO
12.BLINDMAN
13.RETURN OF RINGO
14.RUN MAN RUN
15.DJANGO KILL
16.MY NAME IS NOBODY
17.NAVAJO JOE
18.FACE TO FACE
19.A STRANGER RETURNS
20.HAVE A GOOD FUNERAL MY FRIEND, SARTANA WILL PAY

It took me ages to think of this but to be honest the top 10 is the only definitive list of mine, 11-20 i found harder and they could change in the near future. :slight_smile:

277
  1. the good the bad and the ugly
  2. once upon a time in the west
  3. for a fistfull of dollars
  4. for a few dollars more
  5. run man run
  6. big gun down
  7. face to face

ok these movies are master pieces, so my top 20 excl leone & sollima

  1. Matalo
  2. Django
  3. the big silence
  4. Cementary without crosses
  5. my name is nobody
  6. death rides a horse
  7. django kill
  8. day of anger
  9. blindman
  10. blood at sundown
  11. the big showdown
  12. a bullet for the general
  13. four of the apocalypse
  14. [font=Verdana]KILL THEM ALL AND COME BACK ALONE[/font]
  15. little rita of the west
  16. keoma
  17. they call me trinity
  18. a man called sledge
  19. in a colt´s shadow
  20. bandidos

:slight_smile:

278

Hey guys,

I’m trying to re-calculate votes and noticed a few lists from people who have already posted. No problem, but PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE let me know if it’s a revised list. Otherwise, we’re not going to get very accurate results.

Thanks :wink:

279

Oh, and thanks for keeping on top of that, Stanton.

280

No problem, I like lists.

281

I just finished updating the Top 20 page, if anyone’s interested in seeing the (minor) changes. Oh, and there’s a few dead links on the new titles (Have a Good Funeral, My Friend… Sartana Will Pay, Blood at Sundown, and Ace High), if anyone knows how to fix that.

Thanks for your patience!

282

Ok I’m adding 8 more to my original list.

  1. OUTITW
  2. GBU
  3. FAFDM
  4. The Mercenary
  5. The Great Silence
  6. A Fistful Of Dollars
  7. The Big Gundown
  8. Death Rides A Horse
  9. Companero’s
  10. Run Man Run
  11. A Bullet For The General
  12. Duck You Sucker

13.Cemetery Without Crosses
14.Red Sun
15.Face To Face
16.A Man Called Sledge
17.Tepepa
18.Day Of Anger
19.My Name is Nobody
20.Blindman

283

Hey guys,

Stanton has come up with a new method of calculating votes and if everyone’s cool with it, I would be more than happy to pass the torch on to him. I’ve had a blast updating the list every few weeks, but my pistol hand is a bit shaky nowadays, and Stanton is a much faster gun.

284

can you show us his trick so we can compare and judge?

285

Nono, please, I’m not intending to do the official calculating. Why change a winning team?

The only difference is that i included all 20 films, so there are more SWs in the lower ranks. I also reward the first 3 of every voter with some extra points, but that either makes no great difference, because that’s mostly the same movies (guess which).But the main point is to get a proper Top 20, and in these area there are only minor differences. I’ve done it only for private purposes, and it was (in the beginning) not so much work because I used an already written exel list containing the 150 most important SWs.
Everyone who is interested in a list containing more films should go to fatmandan.de, where now 40 voters have given their Top 40. The winner is also GBU but there are also some interesting above average films like Johnny Yuma within the first 50, and a lot of more obscure SWs at the end of the voting list.

Oh, and your calculating is much more favourable to me, because The Mercenary is on #8 (hehe). Should be on #6, in a better world.

By the way, what’s the meaning of “I’ve had a blast”. Don’t know this phrase.