Vote for Your Top 20 US Westerns


(Novecento) #192

Pat Garrett (the Turner Preview Cut only) and Heaven’s Gate are two of the greatest films I’ve seen - Western or otherwise.


(Stanton) #193

Come on, the difference between the versions is not that great. And it is a masterpiece for me in all 3 versions. I loved it already in the theatrical version, which has its own qualities.


#194

I like the editing better in the Turner version, but the gunshots sound like shit.

What’s the story behind the lyrics being taken out of Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door in one of the cuts?


(scherpschutter) #195

I think they’re in the 05 cut, but not in the Turner Cut


(Stanton) #196

Thy lyrics were in the theatrical version, but there was a phase in which Peckinpah, after Jerry Fielding made negative comments about them, was uncertain if he should use them. The unfinished preview cut (now known as the Turner version) was compiled at that time. There are also 2 scenes missing in that version, one of them made it in the theatrical version (an excellent scene), the other one was first used in an otherwise heavily cut TV version. Both are in the 2005 cut, which basically follows the theatrical version, with adding all but one of the other scenes to be found in the preview cut.


(Novecento) #197

For me, all the supposedly minor trims, alterations, adjustments etc really add up across the picture. I tend to view films as a composite whole and when images or scenes don’t flow nicely into one another I find it disruptive (I am not talking about the plot here). Sure, if you write down on paper all the differences then they might not appear to amount to much, but when I watch it as a whole I find they significantly ruin the overall effect.


(Stanton) #198

I’m also not talking about the plot, which like in all great films is not that important for me.

Still, the film is a masterpiece for me in all 3 versions. But for me the Turner version is the weakest, and the 2005 cut the best.

In the end most things which make the film that special are in all 3 versions to find.


(Novecento) #199

Don’t forget the deleted scene only in the CBS TV cut

I’ve never seen the theatrical version nor the TV version :cry:

I find Peckinpah’s Turner Preview cut to be poetic and elegiac in style. I just don’t feel the same way watching the 2005 cut. Anyway, we have discussed this plenty of times before :grinning:


(Novecento) #200

Any other fans of Heaven’s Gate out there then? I think Michael Cimino was criminally underrated as a director.


#201

I’ve only seen the documentary on the making of Heaven’s Gate, which was very interesting in its own right.

The film is on my list to see though, as I love The Deer Hunter.


(Bill san Antonio) #202

Same here, never seen it and it’s been on my list of films I need to see for ages.


(ENNIOO) #203

Count me as one. Enjoyed it first time around in the 80’s .Like most films not 100% perfect, but one that improves all the time for me.


(tomas) #204

You bet. Great movie. Same goes to Deer Hunter.


(MMcG) #205

I am jumping in late here with a top 20 - never really rated my favourite westerns before and found it hard to balance between older/newer, serious/comedy westerns:
1 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
2 The Hateful Eight
3 Unforgiven
4 Django Unchained
5 The Assassination of Jesse James
6 The Outlaw Josey Wales
7 Tombstone (Kurt Russell)
8 Two Mules For Sister Sara
9 The Wild Bunch
10 Chisum
11 Jesse James (Tyrone Power)
12 True Grit (John Wayne)
13 Rooster Cogburn
14 Rio Bravo
15 Maverick
16 Wyatt Earp (Kevin Costner)
17 Pale Rider
18 Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (Kris Kristofferson)
19 Blazing Saddles
20 Paint Your Wagon


(John Russell) #206

From Hell to Texas is a real sleeper. If you haven’t seen it give it a look.


(Asa) #207
  1. Unforgiven (Eastwood, 1992)
  2. High Plains Drifter (Eastwood, 1973)
  3. True Grit (Coen Brothers, 2010)
  4. The Wild Bunch (Peckinpah, 1969)
  5. The Revenant (Iñárritu, 2015)
  6. Tombstone (Cosmatos, 1993)
  7. Hostiles (Cooper, 2017)
  8. 3:10 to Yuma (Mangold, 2007)
  9. The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (Dominik, 2007)
  10. The Hateful Eight (Tarantino, 2015)
  11. Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (Peckinpah, 1973)
  12. One-Eyed Jacks (Brando, 1961)
  13. The Outlaw Josey Wales (Eastwood, 1976)
  14. True Grit (Hathaway, 1969)
  15. The Quick and the Dead (Raimi, 1995)
  16. The Homesman (Jones, 2014)
  17. Django Unchained (Tarantino, 2012)
  18. Bone Tomahawk (Zahler, 2015)
  19. The Searchers (Ford, 1956)
  20. Pale Rider (Eastwood, 1985)

Haven’t done this in a couple of years so I thought I’d update, although I’ve only added a couple and stirred the other elements a tiny amount.


(Bill san Antonio) #208

Has @John_Welles been around here lately? He compiled the lists but it haven’t been updated for years.

Btw, it would be nice if the top20 would be in the first post of the topic. Now it’s tricky to find.


(scherpschutter) #209

Here’s the list compiled by John (to make things easier for everybody)


(tomas) #210

I think I’ve never done this since I haven’t seen lot of classics, but I am getting through it now…
Does Last Of The Mohicans count?
Aussie flicks probably dont count…
I’m surprised that nobody voted for Missouri Breaks.

  1. Unforgiven
  2. Outlaw Josey Wales
  3. McCabe & Mrs Miller
  4. Hateful 8
  5. Proposition
  6. Last Of The Mohicans
  7. Missouri Breaks
  8. Jeremiah Johnson
  9. Tombstone
  10. Assassination Of Jesse James By Bob Ford
  11. Little Big Man
  12. Deadman
  13. Heaven’s Gate
  14. The Life And Times Of Judge Roy Bean
  15. High Planes Drifter
  16. Deathhunt
  17. Patt Garret & Billy The Kid
  18. Bad Company
  19. Hombre
  20. Cold Mountain
  21. True Grit (2010)

(The Man With a Name) #211

I thought I did. Definitely one of the best.