With 8 old and incomplete lists gone the 1st 50 have slightly changed.
Rank (old) Title Pts (old) Pts (new)
1 The Good, the Bad, the Ugly 2141 1967
3 Once Upon a Time in the West 1794 1665
2 For a Few Dollars More 1800 1656
4 The Great Silence 1346 1286
5 Django 1239 1142
6 A Fistful of Dollars 1214 1087
7 The Big Gundown 1034 953
8 The Mercenary 748 712
9 Death Rides a Horse / Man to Man 738 647
11 Face to Face 628 618
10 Companeros 682 609
12 Duck, You Sucker! 620 575
13 A Bullet for the General 555 526
14 My Name is Nobody 451 385
15 Day of Anger 395 379
16 Cemetery Without Crosses 375 363
17 Django Kill…If You Live, Shoot! 365 354
18 Keoma 344 333
19 Run Man, Run 284 284
21 The Return of Ringo 252 252
20 Blindman 256 247
23 If You Meet Sartana Pray for Your Death 215 215
22 Sabata 251 208
26 10,000 Dollars Blood Money 171 171
24 Mannaja / A Man Called Blade 186 165
25 Navajo Joe 175 156
28 Tepepa 142 131
27 God Forgives…I Don’t 148 129
29 Light the Fuse…Sartana is Coming 125 125
30 And God Said to Cain 119 119
31 A Pistol for Ringo 109 109
32 Johnny Hamlet 106 106
33 The Grand Duel 100 100
34 Matalo! 94 94
35 Massacre Time 92 92
36 Four of the Apocalypse 87 87
37 California 86 86
37 Bandidos 86 86
40 El Puro 81 81
41 Vengeance 78 78
43 Ace High / 4 for an Ave Maria 75 75
39 Arizona Colt 85 74
44 I Want Him Dead 69 69
45 Kill and Pray / Requiescant 68 68
42 The Forgotten Pistolero 77 67
46 Shoot the Living and Pray for the Dead 67 67
47 Django the Bastard 63 63
48 The Hellbenders 63 63
49 Cut Throats Nine 61 61
50 Trinity is Still My Name 60 60
In the lower ranks there is only one more change (SD will cry):
130 Death Walks in Laredo 8 8
85 Days of Violence 22 7
131 A Barrel Full of Dollars 7 7
I am new here and these are my Top 20 though I do many movies unjustice with this collection.
I also must admit that i have only seen some 100 movies by now. The two Sartanas, Sabata and Apocalypsis Joe are in this list mostly due to the outstanding german dubbing. I haven’t seen some popular ones like Matalo, Day of Anger, Requiescant, Tepepa, If You Meet Sartana Pray for Your Death and Cut-Throats Nine. Actually the first three haven’t got any order for me so I threw some dices and placed the Great Slicence on the top. I deliberately ommited all of the Revolution-Western cos I don’t know where to place them.
[size=12pt]1 The Great Silence
2 The Good, the Bad, the Ugly
3 Once Upon a Time in the West[/size]
4 For a Few Dollars More
5 The Big Gundown
6 Keoma
7 Django
8 Cemetery Without Crosses
9 My Name is Nobody
10 Blindman
11 Mannaja
12 Kill Them all and come back alone
13 A Fistfull of Dollars
14 Death rides a horse
15 Light the Fuse…Sartana is Coming
16 I Am Sartana Your Angel of Death
17 Apocalypsis Joe (A Man Called Apocalypse Joe)
18 And God Said to Cain
19 God Forgives…I Don’t
20 Sabata
I have deleted the TOP 20 I made without the Zapatas and my old list is therfore still the one that counts.
I still mean what I wrote about the Zapatas not being real westerns though.
“I don’t consider The Mercenary,A Bullet for the General,Companeros, Duck you sucker and Tepepa real westerns and therfore neither of them are on my list.”
[quote=“Stanton, post:1185, topic:190”]Truth is, I would prefer it if they were in for the simple reason of comparableness.
Maybe you think about it.[/quote]
That’s okay with me. Just ignore this last list of mine and let my old one be the one that counts.
The only thing I did with this new list was to pull The Mercenary, A bullet for the genneral and Companeros out of it and add the lowest three entries instead.
Korano, you mean, you don’t think that this list will change again?
Your new list is full of surprises. Mainly as it had changed nearly completely.
How came you have changed such a lot? Change of taste? What happened to your former # 2 Companeros? Or the other films which made your top 10 before like Cemetery without Crosses, Tepepa, Great Silence.
Interesting that Death Rides a Horse wasn’t in your list before and that GBU is now on top of it. I thought you weren’t very fond of GBU.
A list without The Great Silence and Once Upon a Time in The West is a hell of a list, take it lterally.
Maybee sometime I will reconsider my list too but at the moment i am fine with it though the revolution Westerns have to be dealt with in a better way. I liked the Mercenary pretty much.
That’s a pretty controversial list you’ve got there korano. Once Upon a Time in the West isn’t as good as Death Rides a Horse? And where’s The Great Silence or For a Few Dollars More? Don’t you really rate Leone at all?
[quote=“John Welles, post:1196, topic:190”]:o :o :o You’re right, korano list is pretty mild compared to yours! :)[/quote]I don’t know if it’s that controversial apart from Shotgun. So forgettable movie.
- leave 'em in.
