Vote for Our Official Top 20

Here is my pick.

  1. Blindman
  2. Companeros
  3. Keoma
  4. Mannaja
  5. A reason to live, a reason to die
  6. Matalo
  7. A Man Called Sledge
  8. GBU
  9. DYS
  10. Those Dirty Dogs
  11. Get Mean
  12. A Bullet for Sandoval
  13. Grand Duel
  14. Sabata
  15. Forgotten Pistolero
  16. Great Silence
  17. My Name is Nobody
  18. Today We Kill…Tomorrow We Die
  19. Shoot the Living, Pray for the Dead
  20. Man: Pride and Vengeance

Edited to include man called sledge and Today It’s me tomorrow you

Interesting and unusual list Korano, with Blindman at the top and not so much Leone’s in it.
Also 3 new entries for the complete list.

What’s about Man Called Noon? It’s generally not considered as a SW, but as an euro western.
Well, it was still named by another voter, and definitions are there as much as members, so you can keep it if you like, but I would prefer to have it replaced with a “real” Spag.
Your decision.

most interesting list so far. OUATITW is not even IN it!?

[quote=“stanton, post:702, topic:190”]What’s about Man Called Noon? It’s generally not considered as a SW, but as an euro western.
Well, it was still named by another voter, and definitions are there as much as members, so you can keep it if you like, but I would prefer to have it replaced with a “real” Spag.
Your decision.[/quote]

You’re right Stanton, this probably is more a euro than a spag but it is an italian co production (with Spain and UK) and somehow I’ve always included it in my definition of a spaghetti. But, as you say, there are as many definitions as there are members. :wink:

  1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  2. Once Upon a Time in the West
  3. Fistful of Dynamite
  4. Four of the Apocalypse
  5. California
  6. The Mercenary
  7. Django
  8. For a Few Dollars More
  9. Kill Them All and Come Back Alone
  10. Johnny Hamlet
  11. Keoma
  12. Run Man Run
  13. Death Rides a Horse
  14. The Great Silence
  15. Fistful of Dollars
  16. Mannaja
  17. My Name is Nobody
  18. The Big Gundown
  19. Bandidos
  20. Genius, Two Partners and a Dupe

[quote=“chuck connors brother, post:705, topic:190”]1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
2. Once Upon a Time in the West[/quote]

nononono it’s all wrong! xD

Wasn’t in mine either.

sacrilege!

Yes, I know, there was a little italian involvement on the production side. But it’s clearly one of those brit westerns.

Poor SD had to skip it also, not without some complaining. This western has it’s fans.

I have to admit, I have never seen it.

Seb, you don’t know how damn right you are, as an actual update would be a litttle like this:

  1. The Good, the Bad, the Ugly Leone, Sergio 1604
  2. For a Few Dollars More Leone, Sergio 1353
  3. Once Upon a Time in the West Leone, Sergio 1353

Jesus, what else will happen in this world?

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

HAS THIS WHOLE WORLD GONE CRAZAYYYY???

[quote=“stanton, post:710, topic:190”]Seb, you don’t know how damn right you are, as an actual update would be a litttle like this:

  1. The Good, the Bad, the Ugly Leone, Sergio 1604
  2. For a Few Dollars More Leone, Sergio 1353
  3. Once Upon a Time in the West Leone, Sergio 1353

Jesus, what else will happen in this world?[/quote]

All looks fine to me.
Now if we can just get Return of Ringo in at number 3… :wink:

I’m not saying anything ::slight_smile: ::slight_smile:

[quote=“Phil H, post:712, topic:190”]All looks fine to me.
Now if we can just get Return of Ringo in at number 3… ;)[/quote]

As low as that Phil??? ;D ;D

[quote=“Sebastian, post:703, topic:190”]most interesting list so far. OUATITW is not even IN it!?[/quote]He He. Well, I really like OUATITW, but It wasn;t really my cup of tea. Very well made and I have the highest respect for it but not my fav.

Out of interest do you have to submit just 20 or can the number be higher? (ie 30 or 40)…Or would only the first 20 be counted?

I will correct my list. I was running out of SPW’s I’ve watched so I’ll change Man Called Noon to Shoot the Living, Pray for the Dead as 19.

Only the 1st 20 are counted, but you can name of course as much as you like.

So the one for free I offered you some time ago wouldn’t have get any points either.

Out of interest Silver, your interest won’t result in your long expected, long overdue top 20 list?

[quote=“stanton, post:718, topic:190”]Only the 1st 20 are counted, but you can name of course as much as you like.

So the one for free I offered you some time ago wouldn’t have get any points either.

Out of interest Silver, your interest won’t result in your long expected, long overdue top 20 list?[/quote]

Could be… I’m “struggling” with one at the moment. Of course i’ll possibly be laughed off the forum once it arrives but what the hell… :stuck_out_tongue:

I think you should continue untill Once upon a Time in the West is on the list, be it at n° 251 …