On this day 20 years ago on the 22th January 2006 the first post of this thread written, the voting process had started.
All in all 232 lists were posted here, and also many of them revised since then. To keep the list dynamic I started in recent years to eliminate older lists for every new one posted, so that 32 lists are no longer part of the tabulation.
So here it is, the 20th birthday list generated of 200 individual lists compiled and posted by SW fans:
| Rank | English Title | Director | Points | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | * | The Good, the Bad, the Ugly | * | Leone, Sergio | * | 3913 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 2 | * | Once Upon a Time in the West | * | Leone, Sergio | * | 3422 |
| 3 | * | For a Few Dollars More | * | Leone, Sergio | * | 3244 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 4 | * | The Great Silence | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 2547 |
| 5 | * | The Big Gundown | * | Sollima, Sergio | * | 2189 |
| 6 | * | A Fistful of Dollars | * | Leone, Sergio | * | 2074 |
| 7 | * | Django | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 2005 |
| 8 | * | The Mercenary | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 1457 |
| 9 | * | Death Rides a Horse / Man to Man | * | Petroni, Giulio | * | 1314 |
| 10 | * | Duck, You Sucker! | * | Leone, Sergio | * | 1222 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 11 | * | Companeros | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 1200 |
| 12 | * | Face to Face | * | Sollima, Sergio | * | 1136 |
| 13 | * | A Bullet for the General | * | Damiani, Damiano | * | 1060 |
| 14 | * | Day of Anger | * | Valerii, Tonino | * | 972 |
| 15 | * | Cemetery Without Crosses | * | Hossein, Robert | * | 949 |
| 16 | * | Keoma | * | Castellari, Enzo G. | * | 847 |
| 17 | * | The Return of Ringo | * | Tessari, Duccio | * | 792 |
| 18 | * | My Name is Nobody | * | Leone, Sergio/Valerii, T. | * | 726 |
| 19 | * | Django Kill…If You Live, Shoot! | * | Questi, Giulio | * | 507 |
| 20 | * | Run Man, Run | * | Sollima, Sergio | * | 381 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 21 | * | Tepepa | * | Petroni, Giulio | * | 363 |
| 22 | * | 10,000 Dollars Blood Money | * | Girolami, Romolo | * | 352 |
| 23 | * | If You Meet Sartana Pray for Your Death | * | Parolini, Gianfranco | * | 350 |
| 24 | * | Navajo Joe | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 347 |
| 25 | * | Blindman | * | Baldi, Ferdinando | * | 346 |
| 26 | * | And God Said to Cain | * | Margheriti, Antonio | * | 334 |
| 27 | * | A Pistol for Ringo | * | Tessari, Duccio | * | 299 |
| 28 | * | Sabata | * | Parolini, Gianfranco | * | 289 |
| 29 | * | Bandidos | * | Dallamano, Massimo | * | 264 |
| 30 | * | El puro | * | Mulargia, Edoardo | * | 249 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 31 | * | God Forgives…I Don’t | * | Colizzi, Giuseppe | * | 247 |
| 32 | * | Mannaja / A Man Called Blade | * | Martino, Sergio | * | 241 |
| 33 | * | Massacre Time | * | Fulci, Lucio | * | 234 |
| 34 | * | California | * | Lupo, Michele | * | 225 |
| 35 | * | Kill and Pray / Requiescant | * | Lizzani, Carlo | * | 225 |
| 36 | * | Light the Fuse…Sartana is Coming | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 196 |
| 37 | * | Johnny Hamlet | * | Castellari, Enzo G. | * | 191 |
| 38 | * | The Forgotten Pistolero | * | Baldi, Ferdinando | * | 188 |
| 39 | * | Vengeance | * | Margheriti, Antonio | * | 186 |
| 40 | * | Django the Bastard | * | Garrone, Sergio | * | 177 |
| 41 | * | Four of the Apocalypse | * | Fulci, Lucio | * | 174 |
| 42 | * | The Grand Duel | * | Santi, Giancarlo | * | 156 |
| 43 | * | Shoot the Living and Pray for the Dead | * | Vari, Giuseppe | * | 146 |
| 44 | * | Matalo! | * | Canevari, Cesare | * | 146 |
| 45 | * | The Ruthless Four / Each One for His Own | * | Capitani, Giorgio | * | 142 |
| 46 | * | Arizona Colt | * | Lupo, Michele | * | 136 |
| 47 | * | The Hellbenders | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 132 |
| 48 | * | The Specialists | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 127 |
| 49 | * | Trinity is Still My Name | * | Barboni, Enzo | * | 127 |
| 50 | * | Ace High / 4 for an Ave Maria | * | Colizzi, Giuseppe | * | 124 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 51 | * | The Bounty Killer | * | Martin, Eugenio | * | 123 |
| 52 | * | Dead Men Ride | * | Florio, Aldo | * | 121 |
| 53 | * | A Stranger in Town | * | Vanzi, Luigi | * | 117 |
| 54 | * | Black Jack | * | Baldanello, Gianfranco | * | 117 |
| 55 | * | Django, Prepare a Coffin | * | Baldi, Ferdinando | * | 116 |
| 56 | * | Duel in the Eclipse / Requiem for a Gringo | * | Merino, José Luis | * | 116 |
| 57 | * | A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die | * | Giraldi, Franco | * | 110 |
| 58 | * | Death Sentence | * | Lanfranchi, Mario | * | 108 |
| 59 | * | They Call Me Trinity | * | Barboni, Enzo | * | 108 |
| 60 | * | I Want Him Dead | * | Bianchini, Paolo | * | 105 |
| 61 | * | Johnny Yuma | * | Girolami, Romolo | * | 99 |
| 62 | * | They Call Him Cemetery | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 94 |
| 63 | * | I am Sartana, Your Angel of Death | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 91 |
| 64 | * | Yankee | * | Brass, Tinto | * | 91 |
| 65 | * | Vengeance Is Mine / For 100 000 Dollars per Killing | * | Fago, Giovanni | * | 89 |
| 66 | * | The Price of Power | * | Valerii, Tonino | * | 88 |
| 67 | * | The Dirty Outlaws / El desperado | * | Rossetti, Franco | * | 82 |
| 68 | * | No Room to Die / A Long File of Crosses | * | Garrone, Sergio | * | 78 |
| 69 | * | A Bullet for Sandoval | * | Buchs, Julio | * | 78 |
| 70 | * | The Moment to Kill | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 74 |
| 71 | * | Adios Sabata | * | Parolini, Gianfranco | * | 70 |
| 72 | * | Cut Throats Nine | * | Marchent, Joaquin Luis Rom. | * | 67 |
| 73 | * | Today it’s Me…Tomorrow You | * | Cervi, Tonino | * | 67 |
| 74 | * | The Silent Stranger | * | Vanzi, Luigi | * | 66 |
| 75 | * | Garringo | * | Marchent, Rafael Romero | * | 60 |
| 76 | * | The Stranger Returns | * | Vanzi, Luigi | * | 60 |
| 77 | * | Taste of Violence | * | Hossein, Robert | * | 60 |
| 78 | * | Texas Adios | * | Baldi, Ferdinando | * | 59 |
| 79 | * | Red Sun | * | Young, Terence | * | 59 |
| 80 | * | Cost of Dying / Taste of Death | * | Merolle, Sergio | * | 59 |
| 81 | * | One Silver Dollar | * | Ferroni, Giorgio | * | 57 |
| 82 | * | Have a Good Funeral, My Friend…Sartana Will Pay | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 50 |
| 83 | * | A Hole in the Forehead | * | Vari, Giuseppe | * | 48 |
| 84 | * | Ben and Charlie | * | Lupo, Michele | * | 46 |
| 84 | * | Sonny and Jed | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 46 |
| 86 | * | One after Another | * | Nostro, Nick | * | 46 |
| 87 | * | Long Days of Vengeance | * | Vancini, Florestano | * | 44 |
| 87 | * | I am Sartana, Trade Your Guns for a Coffin / A Fistful of Lead | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 44 |
| 87 | * | Night of the Serpent | * | Petroni, Giulio | * | 44 |
| 90 | * | Long Live Your Death | * | Tessari, Duccio | * | 44 |
| 91 | * | Kill Them All and Come Back Alone | * | Castellari, Enzo G. | * | 43 |
| 92 | * | Cowards Don’t Pray | * | Siciliano, Mario | * | 43 |
| 93 | * | Fighting Fists of Shanghai Joe | * | Caiano, Mario | * | 40 |
| 94 | * | For the Taste of Killing | * | Valerii, Tonino | * | 38 |
| 95 | * | The Last Killer | * | Vari, Giuseppe | * | 37 |
| 96 | * | Five Man Army | * | Taylor, Don | * | 36 |
| 97 | * | They Call Me Hallelujah / Heads I Kill You, Tails You Die | * | Carnimeo, Giuliano | * | 35 |
| 98 | * | Shoot, Gringo…Shoot! | * | Corbucci, Bruno | * | 35 |
| 98 | * | Boot Hill | * | Colizzi, Giuseppe | * | 35 |
| 100 | * | Blood at Sundown / 1 000 Dollars on the Black | * | Cardone, Alberto | * | 34 |
| ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ | ~ |
| 101 | * | A Man Called Sledge | * | Morrow, Vic | * | 34 |
| 101 | * | John the Bastard | * | Crispino, Armando | * | 34 |
| 103 | * | Death Played the Flute | * | Panaccio, Angelo | * | 31 |
| 104 | * | Any Gun Can Play | * | Castellari, Enzo G. | * | 30 |
| 105 | * | Revenge for Revenge | * | Colucci, Mario | * | 28 |
| 105 | * | A Man Called Apocalypse Joe | * | Savona, Leopoldo | * | 28 |
| 107 | * | The Hills Run Red / A River of Dollars | * | Lizzani, Carlo | * | 27 |
| 107 | * | Minnesota Clay | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 27 |
| 109 | * | Silver Saddle | * | Fulci, Lucio | * | 27 |
| 110 | * | Pistoleros | * | Caltabiano, Alfio | * | 25 |
| 111 | * | God Does Not Pay on Saturday / Kill the Wicked | * | Boccia, Tanio | * | 24 |
| 112 | * | Viva Cangaceiro | * | Fago, Giovanni | * | 24 |
| 113 | * | Bullets Don’t Argue | * | Caiano, Mario | * | 23 |
| 114 | * | The Unholy Four / Chuck Mool | * | Barboni, Enzo | * | 22 |
| 115 | * | A Genius, Two Partners and a Dupe / Nobody’s the Greatest | * | Damiani, Damiano | * | 22 |
| 116 | * | W Django | * | Mulargia, Eduardo | * | 21 |
| 117 | * | Hate for Hate | * | Paolella, Domenico | * | 21 |
| 118 | * | Dead Men Don’t Make Shadows | * | Fidani, Demofilo | * | 20 |
| 119 | * | Beyond the Law | * | Stegani Giorgio C. | * | 20 |
| 120 | * | Sartana Does Not Forgive | * | Balcazar, Alfonso | * | 19 |
| 120 | * | Apache Woman | * | Mariuzzo, Giorgio | * | 19 |
| 120 | * | Hate Is My God | * | Gora,Claudio | * | 19 |
| 123 | * | Fort Yuma Gold | * | Ferroni, Giorgio | * | 18 |
| 124 | * | God Made Them… I Kill Them / God Forgives … His Life is Mine | * | Bianchini, Paolo | * | 18 |
| 124 | * | Go with God, Gringo | * | Mulargia, Edoardo | * | 18 |
| 126 | * | The Fury of Johnny Kid | * | Puccini, Gianni | * | 17 |
| 127 | * | A Barrel Full of Dollars | * | Fidani, Demofilo | * | 17 |
| 127 | * | A Reason to Live, A Reason to Die | * | Valerii, Tonino | * | 17 |
| 129 | * | Drummer of Vengeance | * | Gariazzo, Mario | * | 17 |
| 130 | * | Life is Tough, Eh Providence? | * | Petroni, Giulio | * | 16 |
| 130 | * | A Pistol for 100 Coffins | * | Lenzi, Umberto | * | 16 |
| 132 | * | The Price of Death | * | Palli, Enzo Gicca | * | 16 |
| 132 | * | Seven Guns for the MacGregors | * | Giraldi, Franco | * | 16 |
| 132 | * | Machine Gun Killers | * | Bianchini, Paolo | * | 16 |
| 135 | * | Man, Pride, Vengeance | * | Bazzoni, Luigi | * | 15 |
| 136 | * | Death Walks in Laredo | * | Pero, Enzi | * | 13 |
| 136 | * | El Rojo | * | Savona, Leopoldo | * | 13 |
| 136 | * | In a Colt’s Shadow | * | Grimaldi, Giovanni | * | 13 |
| 139 | * | Trinity Sees Red / The Color of the Wind | * | Camus, Mario | * | 12 |
| 139 | * | Seven Dollars on the Red | * | Cardone, Alberto | * | 12 |
| 141 | * | Black Killer | * | Croccolo, Carlo | * | 12 |
| 141 | * | What am I Doing in the Middle of the Revolution? | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 12 |
| 143 | * | Train for Durango | * | Caiano, Mario | * | 11 |
| 144 | * | Ringo and his Golden Pistol | * | Corbucci, Sergio | * | 11 |
| 145 | * | Shotgun | * | Mauri, Roberto | * | 11 |
| 146 | * | And for a Roof a Sky Full of Stars | * | Petroni, Giulio | * | 10 |
| 147 | * | Ringo from Nebraska | * | Bava, Mario | * | 10 |
| 147 | * | The Greatest Robbery in the West | * | Lucidi, Maurizio | * | 10 |
| 149 | * | A Coffin for the Sheriff | * | Caiano, Mario | * | 9 |
| 149 | * | Starblack | * | Grimaldi, Giovanni | * | 9 |
| 151 | * | Viva Maria | * | Malle, Louis | * | 7 |
| 152 | * | Cjamango | * | Mulargia, Edoardo | * | 6 |
| 152 | * | 15 Scaffolds for a Killer | * | Malasomma, Nunzio | * | 6 |
| 154 | * | Tequila Joe | * | Dell’Aquila, Vincenzo | * | 5 |
| 155 | * | Hate Thy Neighbour | * | Baldi, Ferdinando | * | 5 |
| 156 | * | The Belle Star Story | * | Wertmüller, Lina | * | 4 |
| 156 | * | My Name is Pecos | * | Lucidi, Maurizio | * | 4 |