Thanks for all the number crunching work Samuryan. I agree that those who called the film Sartana should confirm what they meant. It is confusing. I have 2 copies of the first Sartana film. One called Sartana, the other is If You Meet etc… This is a common problem with many SW’s, especialy if Django or Sartana figure in the titles!
Hi,
I’m a new member in this Forum, and I like Lists.
So here are my Top 20 out of about 200 Spaghettis I’ve seen, most of them in the last year. But why name 20 when only 12 are used for the poll? Why don’t you gave points for all 20?
- Once upon a Time in the West
- The Good, the Bad, the Ugly
- The Mercenary
- The Great Silence
- For a Few Dollars More
- My Name Is Nobody
- Cemetery without Crosses
- A Fistful of Dollars
- Companeros
- Django
- Blindman
- A Bullet for the General
- Django Kill
- A Fistful of Dynamite
- The Big Gundown
- Boot Hill
- Run, Man, Run
- God Forgives, I Don’t
- Ace High
- Return of Ringo
[quote=“stanton, post:228, topic:190”]Hi,
I’m a new member in this Forum…
- Once upon a Time in the West[/quote]
hoorayy for ouatitw! welcome to the board!
we do give points for all 20, what are you talking about 
I’m referring to the Essential Top 20 Page:
A note to the points #1 - 12 PTS, #2 - 11 … #13- ?
Why not 20 for #1?
go some pages back here and read how they are calculated… i didnt invent the system, but it seems to work pretty good
My Top 20:
- Once upon a Time in the West
- The Good, the Bad, the Ugly
- For a Few Dollars More
- The Great Silence
- A Fistful of Dollars
- A Bullet for the General
- The Big Gundown
- The Mercenary
- My Name Is Nobody
10.A Fistful of Dynamite
11.Face To Face
12.Django
13.Django Kill
14.Companeros
15.Death Rides A Horse
17.Day Of Anger
18.Sabata
19.Four Of The Apocalypse
20.Death Sentence
[quote=“kohlbek, post:232, topic:190”]My Top 20:
- Once upon a Time in the West[/quote]
go go go!
Mt top 20 in no particular order (sort of) apart from no.1
1.Once upon a time in the west
2.The good the bad and the ugly
3.for a few dollars more
4.fuistful of dynamite
5.companeros
6.the mercenary
7.keoma
8.fistful of dollars
9.my name is nobody
10.fighting fists of shanghai joe
11.big gundown
12.face to face
13.django kill
14.great silence
15.django
16.run man run
17.a man called blade
18.sabata
19.return of sabata
20.return of ringo
(i could easily take some out and put others in, this is too hard!)
[quote=“Yodlaf Peterson, post:234, topic:190”]Mt top 20 in no particular order (sort of) apart from no.1
1.Once upon a time in the west
(i could easily take some out and put others in, this is too hard!)[/quote]
yehaw! go go go go go!
where’s samuryan? we should update our top 20 list
Do I detect a hint of bias in favour of OUATITW ???
[quote=“Cian, post:236, topic:190”]Do I detect a hint of bias in favour of OUATITW ???[/quote]damn right!
Hey guys (and gals?),
I just updated the list on the Top 20 page. Sorry about that red Shanghai Joe. I’m not sure why it defaulted to that color. Can somebody be a sport and change it to match the rest of the runner’s up? Please.
Yer a daisy if you do.
(Oh, and congrats to Keoma for fighting it’s way back onto the list, and OUATITW for bumping into second!)
Done.
outatitw is my personal favorite movie of all times, no wonder i cheer everytime it moves up a few points!
A man after my own heart
“once upon a time in the west”
how did it move out of 1st place in the first place, surely this must be most people’s favourite spaghetti (it’s my favourite film of any genre) closely followed by “The good the bad and the ugly”
1.The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
2.Once Upon a Time in the West
3.A Fistful of Dynamite
4.For a Few Dollars More
5.A Fistful of Dollars
6.Four of the Apocalypse
7.Mannaja
8.The Fighting Fists of Shanghai Joe
9.Django
10.The Great Silence
11.The Mercenary
12.My Name is Nobody
13.Companeros
14.Hellbenders
15.Run Man Run
16.Bandidos
17.The Big Gundown
18.Massacre Time
19.Death Rides a Horse
20.Keoma
thanks for your list, I hope more people post their lists so we can update the official page soon
Ok, just for fun I’ve made a slightly different list by giving points to all 20 Films and not only the first 12. In one case of the before mentioned Sartana problem, it must be the Parolini Sartana because in the same List there is also at #20 Blood at Sundown, another english title for Mille dollari sul nero.
There are 2 films I’m not sure about:
1.God Forgives … His Life Is Mine
This must be Dio li crea … io li ammazzo! (German: Bleigericht) Right?
2.Rough Justice
Can’t find it anywhere. Anyone who knows the director or the original title?
Many members have by now only named 10 or 12 Films. It would be great if anyone could alter it up to 20. And the guys who gave their lists no order, please, try it, even if it’s difficult.
There are also some non Spaghettis which should be replaced:
El Topo
Viva Maria
The Quick and the Dead
and in my opinion also Red Sun, which is a european western, no Spaghetti.
Viva Maria and Red Sun are considered spaghettis on this board, but didn’t get enough points.
All eurowesterns that are italian or partly italian are considered spaghettis here, that’s the criteria.
Rough Justice: Belva, La - The Spaghetti Western Database
God Forgives: His life is mine: http://www.spaghetti-western.net/index.php/Dio_li_crea…_Io_li_ammazzo%21
Red Sun: It is partly shot in Italy and the production company “Ocenia Film” is Italian, what make the a Spaghetti Western. And the plot takes place in Arizona. So everything ok 