Favorite Non–Spaghetti Westerns

hannie colder
el condor
magnificent seven ride
wild bunch

let’s see, but i haven’t seen that much US westerns

Outlaw Josey Wales
Unforgiven
High Planes Drifter
Assasination of Jesse James by coward …
Mountain Men (with Heston)
Proposition
McCabe and Mrs. Miller
Quigley Down Under
Jeremiah Johnson

and worst ones :
3:10 Yuma (remake)
Wild Bill (Walter Hill)
Silverado

Chato’s Land
The Desperados
The Wild Bunch
The Professionals
Vera Cruz
The Magnificent Seven
Arrowhead
The Alamo [Original]
Gatling Gun
The 0x-Bow Incident
They Died With Their Boots On

The Wild Bunch and Unforgiven are at the very top of my favorite movies ever.

Other favorite westerns: McCabe & Ms. Miller, Jeremiah Johnson (I like the snow movies), Hombre, and anything Eastwood did, especially Josey Wales.

Classic era westerns are usually not my thing.

I like Wyatt Earp, reason why it is underrated are not clear to me (are there really so much good westerns, especially since 80s, so that Earp can be dismissed?).
I didn’t like Dance with the wolves on the other hand.

Recently I liked True Grit remake (which can’t be said for 3:10 to Yuma).

1. Unforgiven (1992)
2. High Plains Drifter (1973)
3. The Proposition (2005)
4. The Wild Bunch (1969)
5. True Grit (2010)
6. The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007)
7. 3:10 to Yuma (2007)
8. Tombstone (1993)
9. Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (1973)
10. The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976)

With nods to Django Unchained (2012), Rango (2011), The Quick & the Dead (1995), Pale Rider (1985), The Good, the Bad, the Weird (2008), No Country For Old Men (2007), True Grit (1969), The Magnificent Seven (1960), Wyatt Earp (1994) and High Noon (1952).

The first ten of my official top20

1.The Outlaw Josey Wales (Clint Eastwood-1976)
2.Major Dundee (Sam Peckinpah-1965)
3.Rio Bravo (Howard Hawks-1959)
4.El Dorado (Howard Hawks-1966)
5.High Plains Drifter (Clint Eastwood-1973)
6.True Grit (Henry Hathaway-1969)
7.The Unforgiven (Clint Eastwood-1992)
8.Hour of the Gun (John Sturges-1967)
9.Vera Cruz (Robert Aldrich-1954)
10.Chisum (Andrew V. McLaglen-1970)

Honored mentioned:

The Sons of Katie Elder (Henry Hathaway-1965)
The Man from Laramie (Anthonny Man-1955)
The Man who Shot Liberty Valance (John Ford-1962)
The Hired Hand (Peter Fonda-1971)
Bandolero! (Andrew V. McLaglen-1968)

Wild Bill (Walter Hill)

You called that as one of your worst, but I have to admit to having a soft side for the film. I bought the DVD, but still watch it each time it comes on television. I’m attracted to it like a motorist rubbernecking at a car accident, I suppose.

the wild bunch 1969
haunie caulder 1971
el condor 1970
the hunting party 1971
the magnificent seven ride 1972
100 riflus 1969

Gotta have

the Assasination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

that film is amazing

I concur. I was absolutely blown away by that film.

Best performance of the year by Casey Affleck in it. I had to see it, after I saw him in the trailer, and after the film, I wanted to give him 10 oscars for that terrififc piece of acting.
I also enjoyed Andrew Dominik’s Killing Them Softly very much, although it is a very different movie (nothing grand or elegiac in this short and to the point satire of the recent gangster movies).

High Plains Drifter
Two Mules for Sister Sara
The Outlaw Josey Wales
Pale Rider
Unforgiven
Hang 'em High
Back to the Future Part III
3:10 to Yuma (remake)
Shanghai Noon

High Plains Drifter Two Mules for Sister Sara The Outlaw Josey Wales Pale Rider Unforgiven Hang 'em High

I like the majority of those, too. Never been too fond of HANG’EM HIGH, though. It’s decent, but rates low on my Eastwood scale.

Just watched it. Excellent film, imo.

2008 Appaloosa – written by Robert B. Parker / Robert Knott, directed by Ed Harris.
2007 The Assassination of Jesse James By the Coward Robert Ford – by Andrew Dominik.
2006 Seraphim Falls – directed by David Von Ancken, natural light photography by John Toll.
2003 Monte Walsh remake – written by Jack Schaefer, directed by Simon Wincer.
2003 Open Range – Lauren Payne story directed by Kevin Costner.
1996 Lone Star – written and directed by John Sayles.
1992 Conagher – written by Louis L’Amour, directed by Reynaldo Villalobos.
1988 The Tracker – written by Kevin Jarre, directed by John Guillermin.
1987 The Quick and the Dead – written by Louis L’Amour, directed by Robert Day.
1986 The Red-Headed Stranger – written and directed by William D. Wittliff himself.
1982 The Ballad of Gregorio Cortez – directed by Robert M. Young, photographed by Reynaldo Villalobos.
1982 Barbarosa – written William D. Wittliff, directed by Fred Schipisi.
1980 Tom Horn – directed by William Wiard.
1980 The Long Riders – written by the Keach brothers, directed by Walter Hill.
1979 Eagle’s Wing – directed by Anthony Harvey.
1978 Heartland – directed by Richard Pearce.
1978 Comes a Horseman – directed by Alan J. Pakula, photographed (wow!) by Gordon Willis.
1976 The Shootist – written by Glendon Swarthout, dircted by Don Siegel.
1975 I Will Fight No More Forever – directed by Richard T. Heffron.
1973 Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid – written by Rudolph Wurlitzer, directed by Sam Peckinpah.
1972 Ulzana’s Raid – written by Alan Sharp, directed by Robert Aldrich.
1972 Junior Bonner – directed by Sam Peckinpah.
1972 Jeremiah Johnson – directed by Sydney J. Pollack.
1972 The Cowboys – directed by Mark Rydell.
1972 Buck and the Preacher – directed by Sidney Poiter and Joseph Sargent.
1971 McCabe & Mrs. Miller – written by Robert McLeod, directed Robert Altman.
1971 Lawman – written by Gerald Wilson, directed by Michael Winner.
1971 The Last Picture Show – written by Larry McMurtry, directed by Peter Bogdanovich.
1971 The Hired Hand – written by Alan Sharp, directed by Peter Fonda.
1971 A Gunfight – directed Lamont Johnson.
1970 The Wild Rovers – directed by Blake Edwards.
1970 Monte Walsh – written by Jack Schaefer, directed by William A. Fraker.
1970 A Man Called Horse – written by Dorothy M. Johnson, directed by Elliot Silverstein.
1969 The Wild Bunch – written by Waldo Green, directed by Sam Peckinpah.
1969 True Grit – written by Charles Portis / Marguerite Roberts, directed Henry Hathaway.
1969 Tell Them Willie Boy Is Here – written and directed Abraham Polonsky.
1969 Support Your Local Sheriff – directed by Burt Kennedy.
1969 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid – directed by George Roy Hill.
1969 100 Rifles – directed by Tom Gries.
1968 Will Penny – directed by Rom Gries.
1968 The Stalking Moon – directed by Robert Mulligan.
1968 Bandolero! – directed by Andrew V. McLaglen.
1967 Hour of the Gun – written by Leon Uris, directed by John Sturges.
1967 Hombre – written by Elmore Leonard, directed by Martin Ritt.
1966 The Professionals – directed by Richard Brooks.
1966 Duel at Diablo – directed by Ralph Nelson.
1966 The Appaloosa – directed by Sidney J. Furie.
1965 The Shooting – written by Carole Eastman, directed by Monte Hellman.
1965 Ride In the Whirlwind – written by Jack Nicholson, directed by Monte Hellman.
1964 Rio Conchos – directed by Gordon Douglas.
1963 Hud – written by Larry McMurtry, directed by Martin Ritt.
1962 Ride the High Country – directed by Sam Peckinpah.
1962 Lonely Are the Brave – written by Dalton Trumbo, directed by David Miller.
1962 Geronimo – directed by Arnold Laven.
1961 One-Eyed Jacks – directed by Marlon Brando.
1960 The Unforgiven – written by Alan LeMay, directed by John Huston.
1960 Flaming Star – directed by Don Siegel.
1960 Comanche Station – written by Burt Kennedy, directed by Budd Boetticher.
1959 Warlock – directed by Edward Dmytryk.
1959 The Last Train From Gun Hill – directed by John Sturges.
1959 The Hanging Tree – written by Dorothy M. Johnson, directed by Delmer Daves.
1958 The Wonderful Country – directed by Robert Parrish.
1958 Tonka – directed by Lewis R. Foster for Disney.
1958 Ride Lonesome – written by Burt Kennedy, directed by Budd Boetticher.
1958 The Law and Jake Wade – directed by John Sturges.
1957 The Tin Star – directed by Anthony Mann.
1957 3:10 to Yuma – written by Elmore Leonard, directed by Delmer Daves.
1956 7 Men From Now – written by Burt Kennedy, directed by Budd Boetticher.
1956 The Searchers – written by Alan LeMay / Frank S. Nugent, directed by John Ford.
1956 Red Sundown – directed by Jack Arnold.
1956 Man From Del Rio– directed by Harry Horner.
1956 Bandido – directed by Richard Fleischer.
1956 Backlash – directed by John Sturges.
1955 The Man From Laramie – directed by Anthony Mann.
1955 The Last Comand – directed Frank Lloyd.
1954 Track of the Cat – directed by William A. Wellman.
1954 Masterson of Kansas – directed by William Castle.
1953 Shane – written by Jack Schaefer / A.B. Guthrie , directed by George Stevens.
1953 The Naked Spur – directed by Anthony Mann.
1953 Gun Fury 3-D – directed by Raoul Walsh.
1953 Hondo 3-D – written by Louis L’Amour, directed by John Farrow.
1953 The Charge at Feather River 3-D – directed by Gordon Douglas.
1952 Ride the Man Down – written by Luke Short, directed by Joseph Kane.
1952 Rancho Notorious – directed by Fritz Lang.
1952 The Lusty Men – directed by Robert Parrish.
1952 The Big Sky – directed by Howard Hawks.
1951 Westward the Women – directed by William A. Wellman.
1951 Viva Zapata! – written by John Steinbeck, directed by Elia Kazan.
1951 High Noon – written by Carl Foreman, directed by Fred Zinnemann.
1951 Apache Drums – produced by Val Lewton, directed by Hugo Fregonese.
1951 Along the Great Divide – directed by Raoul Walsh.
1950 Wagon Master – written by Frank S. Nugent, directed by John Ford.
1950 The Gunfighter – directed by Henry King.
1950 Devil’s Doorway – written by Guy Trosper, directed by Anthony Mann.
1950 Ambush – written by Luke Short, directed by Sam Wood.
1949 She Wore a Yellow Ribbon – written by Frank S. Nugent, directed by John Ford.
1949 Colorado Territory – directed by Raoul Walsh.
1948 Red River – directed by Howard Hawks.
1948 Four Faces West – directed by Alfred E. Green.
1948 Fort Apache – weitten by Frank S. Nugent, directed by John Ford.
1948 Blood On the Moon – written by Luke Short, directed by Robert Wise.
1947 Sea of Grass – directed by Elia Kazan.
1947 Ramrod – written by Luke Short, directed by Andre deToth.
1947 Pursued – directed by Raoul Walsh.
1946 My Darling Clementine – directed by John Ford.
1946 Duel In the Sun – directed by Victor Fleming.
1941 Western Union – the Zane Grey story directed by Fritz Lang.
1940 The Westerner – directed by William Wyler.
1940 The Return of Frank James – directed by Fritz Lang.
1940 The Mark of Zorro – directed by Rouben Mamoulian.
1939 Stagecoach – written by Dudley Nichols, directed by John Ford.
1939 Jesse James – directed by Henry King.

Sorry, no Clint.
Clint is a bore.

My favorites in no particular order:

Doc (1971)
The Hired Hand (1971)
Posse (1975)
The McMasters (1970)
Monte Walsh (1970)
The Wild Bunch
Chato’s Land (1972)
Oklahoma Crude (1973)

Fine bunch of westerns there. Like alot of 70’s westerns myself.

I like to think of the 70’s as the “experimental era” for westerns because we had so many different ways of presenting the west, and also another favorite of mine is The Ballad of Cable Hogue.

  1. The Man From Laramie (1955, Mann)
  2. High Noon (1952, Zinnemann)
  3. The Big Country (1958, Wyler)
  4. The Gunfighter (1950, King)
  5. The Wild Bunch (1969, Peckinpah)
  6. Man of the West (1958, Mann)
  7. 3:10 to Yuma (1957, Daves)
  8. Forty Guns (1957, Fuller)
  9. My Darling Clementine (1946, Ford)
  10. Buchanan Rides Alone (1958, Boetticher)

[quote=“deathrides, post:239, topic:103”]1. The Man From Laramie (1955, Mann)
2. High Noon (1952, Zinnemann)
3. The Big Country (1958, Wyler)
4. The Gunfighter (1950, King)
5. The Wild Bunch (1969, Peckinpah)
6. Man of the West (1958, Mann)
7. 3:10 to Yuma (1957, Daves)
8. Forty Guns (1957, Fuller)
9. My Darling Clementine (1946, Ford)
10. Buchanan Rides Alone (1958, Boetticher)[/quote]

Interesting list. All films I like (with the exception of My Darling Clementine, I never could get into that movie), although only 2 and 4 are in my actual Top 10 (6 and 7 are close). I remember a list from a website or forum, made by members, with Mann also in first place, but not with this movie, but Man of the West.
Mann seems to be the man.

Time to make a new list myself. Soon in this theatre