Yep :(.
[quote=āSundance, post:1162, topic:660ā]The good thing with AFOD is that if the new restoration does come out somewhere (I would think it willā¦) then we will have two discs with excellent image quality and we can choose between the two color schemes regardless of which one of them is actually the correct one. ( I am of course only speaking as someone who wants the English tracks, different situations for different audiences
)
With GBU even if the new colors are exactly the way they are supposed to it still has the shitty downmixed mono track (I still donāt know if this is on purpose or if they made an error since the original mono was certainly restored) and the scene Leone didnāt want. And unless you know and are satisfied with Italian only, there is no alternative (the old MGM BD is an abomination).
Personally I think I even prefer the original shorter version but maybe weāll never see it again.
Considering they treat their films like this Tell MGM it's time ā NOW ā to save John Wayne's The Alamo before it's lost forever
As for OUATITW, from what I have understood a lot of DVDs used to have incorrect colors, and some of them on purpose. Something about the equipment they were watched on and how they needed to POP from the screen or something. And I think DVD canāt even present all the colors as accurately as Blu-Ray.
For example Mad Max 2 on DVD was quite golden/brown and the Blu-Ray (which according to some Mad Max experts is how the actual film prints look) looks quite different: http://www.caps-a-holic.com/hd_vergleiche/multi_comparison.php?disc1=2453&disc2=2448&cap1=22618&cap2=22576&art=full&image=0&hd_multiID=252&action=1&lossless=#vergleich (just put the mouse cursor over the image to switch between the Blu and DVD).
That said, wouldnāt surprise me if the CVC is actually closest to what it should be (but how can we knowā¦). If I have understood correctly the technicolor prints (but is Leoneās copy technicolor or eastman or) shouldnāt have degraded much at all if they have been stored well. But⦠but. Yeah.
And I know absolutely nothing about technicolor and Eastmancolor and whatevercolor and prints dye transfers and stuff. ;)[/quote]
So whatās the deal with FAFDM? For a neophyte, what Iāve been able to glean is that the best idea for fans is the German Blu releases of FOD & FAFDM, and for DYS is the Italian release? Is that about right? As far as GBU, I donāt think that any region has ever had a proper HD version of the theatrical cut, and the HD versions of the extended cut all use the new sound mix :(. Mad Max 2 is one of my all-time favorite films, I hadnāt heard about that, itās fascinating. Yeah, Fox treat their films appallingly. They did seamless branching on all of the Alien films in the boxed set, so I donāt want to hear that they canāt. At the LEAST, they couldāve spliced the proper mono together with the downmix for the new footage. Thereās no excuse. And between their indifference and the state of the physical media market, I donāt see it getting fixed. As far as film prints, I think the chance of seeing much of anything in 35mm is nonexistant now, but itās worth noting that since Leone of course shot in Techniscope and then blew it up later, most prints of the film likely looked pretty haggard, and without Leone around to ask or his DP (and Iām skeptical about listening to them lately anyway with many of the many changes which have happened lately), exactly what the films are āsupposed to look likeā is admittedly somewhat debatable these days.