Alternative Top 20

Town Hall
21

[quote=“Phil H, post:18, topic:1671”]@ Frank Talby

Except…I just noticed that Companeros has slipped onto your list.
Another which is already in the official Top 20 :D[/quote]

I overlooked that one on Frank’s list…

22
  1. Bandidos
  2. Tepepa
  3. El Precio de un Hombre/The Bounty Killer
  4. Il Ritorno di Ringo/Return of Ringo
  5. Il Pistolero dell’Ave Maria/The Forgotten Pistolero
  6. E Dio disse a Caino…/And God spoke to Cain
  7. Gli Specialisti/The Specialists
  8. I Vigliacchi non pregano/Cowards don’t pray
  9. Un Dollaro tra I denti/A Stranger in Town
  10. Dio non paga il Sabato/Kill the Wickeds
  11. Quanto costa Morire/The Cost of Dying
  12. I Lunghi Giorni della Vendetta/Long days of Vengeance
  13. Per 100.000 t’ammazzo/Vengeance is mine
  14. Black Jack
  15. Ballata per un Pistolero/Pistoleros
  16. Dio perdona… Io no!/God forgives, I don’t
  17. Oggi a mé, domani a té!/Today it’s me, tomorrow it’s you
  18. Sledge/A man called Sledge
  19. Continuavano a chiamarlo Trinità/Trinity is still my name
  20. Johnny Yuma
23

ah my bad… top 19 vol 3

  1. Navajo Joe
  2. Hellbenders
  3. One Silver Dollar
  4. Kill Them All and Come Back Alone
  5. Bullets Don’t Argue
  6. The Hills Run Red
  7. A Minute To Pray, A Second To Die
  8. California
  9. A Pistol For Ringo
  10. A Stranger in Town
  11. Django The Bastard
  12. No Room To Die
  13. Today We Kill, Tomorrow We Die
  14. Viva Django
  15. Fort Yuma Gold
  16. Pistoleros
  17. Adios Sabata
  18. Arizona Colt
  19. Jonathan of the Bears
24

No, my only concern is that we don’t list films already in the official Top 20. If they are already in your personal Top 20 that’s fine. The idea is to see which films outside of those already voted the most popular are universally considered worth seeing also by forum members.

25

All these lists!

Hey Phil, doesn’t this remind you of “High Fidelity” as well? :smiley: :smiley: :smiley:

26

[quote=“Dillinger, post:25, topic:1671”]All these lists!

Hey Phil, doesn’t this remind you of “High Fidelity” as well? :smiley: :smiley: :D[/quote]

Oh yes :smiley:

I have to be honest when I read that book (and Fever Pitch too) I thought Nick Hornby had been spying on me. ;D

27

Do the boys in “High Fidelity” make top3 or top5 lists? I can’t remember…

28

Top 5

:wink:

29

Includes an “extended” scene of Steiger and the haughty stagecoach passenger. LOL

30

Makes more sense than just three…

31

in no particular order & likely to change in the near future…

Killer Kid
32 Calibre Killer
Shango
7 Dollars on the Red
God’s Gun
My Name is Shanghai Joe
A Man Called Apocalypse Joe
Johnny Hamlet
W Django
Preparati la bara!
Yankee
Fistful of Lead / Sartana’s Here… Trade Your Pistol for a Coffin
Navajo Joe
They Call Me Hallelujah
The Hills Run Red
The Hellbenders
The Specialist
$10,000 Blood Money
Hole In The Forehead
Barrel Full of Dollars

32

Nice one… some Steffens in it and even a Fidani!

33

Yeah, apparantly I’m quite fond of Steffen…

I really like Fidani, as I’m sure is apparant by now from my other posts

Need to watch this one again soon… I remember liking it a lot

34

My alternative top 20

  1. BLINDMAN
  2. HELLBENDERS
  3. A PISTOL FOR RINGO
  4. A MINUTE TO PRAY A SECOND TO DIE
  5. BLOOD AT SUNDOWN
  6. THE GRAND DUEL
  7. VIVA DJANGO(TERENCE HILL)
    8.HATE THY NEIGHBOUR
    9.THE MAN FROM NOWHERE
  8. THE PRICE OF POWER
    11.CALIFORNIA
  9. MINNESOTA CLAY
  10. FIGHTING FISTS OF SHANGHAI JOE
  11. GARRINGO
  12. A MAN CALLED BLADE
    16.JONATHAN OF THE BEARS
  13. THE RUTHLESS FOUR
    18.THE FORGOTTEN PISTOLERO
    19.CUT THROATS NINE
    20.THE STRANGER RETURNS
    still many SW’s to see so both my lists will change! :slight_smile:
35

Maybe these:

1 El Puro
2 Blindman
3 Boot Hill
4 Matalo!
5 God Forgives…I Don’t
6 The Specialists
7 Duel in the Eclipse
8 A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
9 Ace High
12 The Return of Ringo
13 And God Said to Cain
10 Dead Men Ride
11 The Last Killer
14 Trinity is Still My Name
15 John the Bastard
16 10 000 Dollars Blood Money
17 Shoot, Gringo…Shoot!
18 Today it’s Me…Tomorrow You
19 Navajo Joe
20 They Call Me Hallelujah / Heads I Kill You, Tails You Die

I’m glad to admit that 3 of our forum’s Top 20 are not even amongst my top 50. Well …

36

10.000 Dollars Blood Money (Guerrieri)
Ace High (Colizzi)
And God Said to Cain (Margheriti)
Bounty Killer, The (Martín)
Fighting Fists of Shanghai Joe, The (Caiano)
Five Man Army, The (Zingarelli)
Four of the Apocalypse (Fulci)
Grand Duel, The (Santi)
Have a Good Funeral, My Friend… Sartana Will Pay (Carnimeo)
Hellbenders, The (Corbucci)
I Am Sartana Your Angel of Death (Carnimeo)
Johnny Hamlet (Castellari)
Kill and Pray (Lizzani)
Navajo Joe (Corbucci)
Price of Power, The (Valerii)
Savage Guns (Fidani)
Sonny and Jed (Corbucci)
Trinity is Still My Name (Barboni)
Vengeance Is Mine (Fago)
Yankee (Brass)

37

Btw I noticed that not many people have been putting Sabata in to their alternative top 20. I remember Sabata used to be in the Real top 20 but was overtaken recently. Maybe people still think its on the Real top 20 list and therefore are not including it in their alternative list.

38

add Minnesota Clay as my #20. no need to repost my list.

Sabata is on my original top 20 (#19) but I did see that as well.

39

[quote=“Col. Douglas Mortimer, post:37, topic:1671”]Btw I noticed that not many people have been putting Sabata in to their alternative top 20. I remember Sabata used to be in the Real top 20 but was overtaken recently. Maybe people still think its on the Real top 20 list and therefore are not including it in their alternative list.[/quote]Not much nominations to Mannaja either which used to be in top20 too.

But neither of these films wouldn’t be in my personal top50 list anyway.

40

[quote=“Frank Talby, post:38, topic:1671”]add Minnesota Clay as my #20. no need to repost my list.

Sabata is on my original top 20 (#19) but I did see that as well.[/quote]

Done