Alternative Top 20

Town Hall
181

Here’s a list with the caveat that I need to see many more spaghettis before I feel this will be truly definitive!

  1. Light the Fuse, Sartana is Coming
  2. Death Sentence
  3. Ace High
  4. God Forgives, I Don’t
  5. Tepepa
  6. Return of Ringo
  7. A Stranger in Town
  8. And God Said to Cain
  9. The Forgotten Pistolero
  10. If You Meet Sartana, Pray For Your Death
  11. A Pistol For Ringo
  12. The Stranger Returns
  13. They Call Him Cemetery
  14. Have a Good Funeral…Sartana Will Pay!
  15. $10,000 Blood Money
  16. Trinity is Still My Name
  17. Any Gun Can Play
  18. Texas, Adios!
  19. Few Dollars for Django
  20. Keoma
182

[quote=“Cat Stevens, post:181, topic:1671”]Here’s a list with the caveat that I need to see many more spaghettis before I feel this will be truly definitive!

  1. Light the Fuse, Sartana is Coming
  2. Death Sentence
  3. Ace High
  4. God Forgives, I Don’t
  5. Tepepa
  6. Return of Ringo
  7. A Stranger in Town
  8. And God Said to Cain
  9. The Forgotten Pistolero
  10. If You Meet Sartana, Pray For Your Death
  11. A Pistol For Ringo
  12. The Stranger Returns
  13. They Call Him Cemetery
  14. Have a Good Funeral…Sartana Will Pay!
  15. $10,000 Blood Money
  16. Trinity is Still My Name
  17. Any Gun Can Play
  18. Texas, Adios!
  19. Few Dollars for Django
  20. Keoma[/quote]

A good list. But Keoma is already in the Official Top 20 at #15. Could you pick a replacement?

183

My first alternate top 20:

  1. The Return of Ringo (Tessari)
  2. Death Sentence (Lanfranchi)
  3. Johnny Hamlet (Castellari)
  4. Bandidos (Dallamano)
  5. A Hole in the Forehead (Vari)
  6. A Pistol for Ringo (Tessari)
    7 . Yankee (Brass)
  7. $100,000 for a Massacre (Fago)
  8. California (Lupo)
  9. Long Live Your Death (Tessari)
    11.The Specialists (Corbucci)
  10. $10,000 Blood Money (Guerrieri)
  11. Seven Dollars on the Red (Cardone)
  12. Dead Men Ride (Florio)
  13. Train for Durango (Caiano)
  14. Price of Power (Valerii)
  15. Fury of Johnny Kidd (Puccini)
  16. Arizona Colt (Lupo)
  17. A Bullet for Sandoval (Buchs)
  18. The Last Killer (Vari)
184

Wow. Really? I guess I just wasn’t looking for it that high in the list.

Let’s replace it with The Specialist.

185

Ok, here is the new and altered one:

1 El puro
2 Boot Hill
3 Blindman
4 Matalo!
5 The Last Killer
6 Duel in the Eclipse
7 God Forgives…I Don’t
8 A Bullet for Sandoval
9 Ace High
10 10 000 Dollars Blood Money
11 The Specialists
12 A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
13 The Return of Ringo
14 They Call Me Hallelujah / Heads I Kill You, Tails You Die
15 And God Said to Cain
16 John the Bastard
17 Shoot, Gringo…Shoot!
18 Today it’s Me…Tomorrow You
19 Navajo Joe
20 Have a Good Funeral, My Friend…Sartana Will Pay

186

John The Bastard has gone up a bit in my thoughts after a recent viewing. Previously disliked.

187

[quote=“Cat Stevens, post:184, topic:1671”]Wow. Really? I guess I just wasn’t looking for it that high in the list.

Let’s replace it with The Specialist.[/quote]

Done

188

[quote=“Stanton, post:185, topic:1671”]Ok, here is the new and altered one:

1 El puro
2 Boot Hill
3 Blindman
4 Matalo!
5 The Last Killer
6 Duel in the Eclipse
7 God Forgives…I Don’t
8 A Bullet for Sandoval
9 Ace High
10 10 000 Dollars Blood Money
11 The Specialists
12 A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
13 The Return of Ringo
14 They Call Me Hallelujah / Heads I Kill You, Tails You Die
15 And God Said to Cain
16 John the Bastard
17 Shoot, Gringo…Shoot!
18 Today it’s Me…Tomorrow You
19 Navajo Joe
20 Have a Good Funeral, My Friend…Sartana Will Pay[/quote]

So Trinity and Dead Men drop out and Sartana and Sandoval come in, correct?

189

Phil,

I read back a page or two and see that you are accounting for the “fluctuation” at #20 in the Top 20 list. So I have amended my list (just a few posts above) inserting The Return of Ringo at #1 and moving everything else down one slot (and dropping Lenzi).

190

Seems so, I haven’t checked the old one, and I thought there would be more differences. The order isn’t important?

Trinity, hmmm … should have kept it. I have dropped it only because it is a comedy at first and only then a western.

191

[quote=“Stanton, post:190, topic:1671”]Seems so, I haven’t checked the old one, and I thought there would be more differences. The order isn’t important?

Trinity, hmmm … should have kept it. I have dropped it only because it is a comedy at first and only then a western.[/quote]

Order isn’t important at all for this as every pick gets 1 point.

192

Seems like top 19-21 could be a thread in itself :slight_smile:

193

[quote=“Stanton, post:185, topic:1671”]Ok, here is the new and altered one:

1 El puro
2 Boot Hill
3 Blindman
4 Matalo!
5 The Last Killer
6 Duel in the Eclipse
7 God Forgives…I Don’t
8 A Bullet for Sandoval
9 Ace High
10 10 000 Dollars Blood Money
11 The Specialists
12 A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
13 The Return of Ringo
14 They Call Me Hallelujah / Heads I Kill You, Tails You Die
15 And God Said to Cain
16 John the Bastard
17 Shoot, Gringo…Shoot!
18 Today it’s Me…Tomorrow You
19 Navajo Joe
20 Have a Good Funeral, My Friend…Sartana Will Pay[/quote]
from 1. to 14. the list looks like tower! ha ha

194

Which was my intention …

195

old list

1. God forgives I don’t
2. Bandidos
3. Return of Ringo
4. El Puro
5. 10000$ blood money
6. Viva Django
7. They call me Hallelujah
8. Taste of Death
9. Sonny & Jed
10. Bullet for Sandoval
11. Black Jack
12. Massacre time
13. Yankee
14. Death Sentence
15. Minnesota Clay
16. No room to die
17. Stranger returns
18. Ruthless Four
19. Dead Men Ride
20. Fighting Fists of Shanghai Joe

new one

  1. God forgives I don’t
  2. Bandidos
  3. El Puro
  4. 10000$ blood money
  5. Stranger in Town
  6. They call me Hallelujah
  7. Taste of Death
  8. Sonny & Jed
  9. Bullet for Sandoval
  10. Black Jack
  11. Massacre time
  12. Yankee
  13. Death Sentence
  14. No room to die
  15. Stranger returns
  16. Ruthless Four
  17. Dead Men Ride
  18. Fighting Fists of Shanghai Joe
  19. The Specialist
  20. Adios Gringo
196

list’s never end

197
  1. Sabata
  2. Adios Sabata
  3. Death Sentence
  4. Five Man Army
  5. Blindman
  6. Bandidos
  7. They Call Him Cemetery
  8. 10000 Dollars Blood Money
  9. Trinity is Still My Name
  10. God Forgives, I Don’t
  11. If You Meet Sartana Prey For Your Death
  12. Light The Fuse Sartana is Coming
  13. Ace High
  14. Johnny Hamlet
  15. The Price of Power
  16. A Pistol For Ringo
  17. Matalo
  18. Massacre Time
  19. Viva Django (Terence Hill)
  20. Tepepa
198

Good list. And welcome to the forum.
I like the user name to by the way. Neville ‘fuckin’ Bartos. 8)

One of my favourite scenes from one of my favourite films.

199

Here is my Alternative Top 20 list

  1. E Dio disse a Caino
  2. Un dollaro bucato
  3. Sole rosso
  4. Una nuvola di polvere, un grido di morte… arriva Sartana
  5. Per pochi dollari ancora
  6. Blindman
  7. Buon funerale amigos, paga Sartana
  8. Ognuno per sè
  9. Anda muchacho, spara!
  10. Mille dollari sul nero
  11. Matalo!
  12. Django il bastardo
  13. Il pistolero dell’Ave Maria
  14. 10.000 dollari per un massacro
  15. I lunghi giorni della vendetta
  16. Se incontri Sartana prega per la tua morte
  17. Arizona Colt
  18. Gli specialisti
  19. El Desperado
  20. Dio perdona… io no
200

Heres my list , 1. JOHNNY YUMA 2. FIGHTING FISTS OF SHANGHAI JOE
3. STRANGER RETURNS
4. A GUN FOR A 100 COFFINS (Lenzi 1968, does no one like this film ?)
5. A BULLET FOR SANDOVAL
6. THE RED THE YELLOW + THE WHITE ( Sorry its years since i saw this Corbucci film, which everyone seems to hate , T.Milian as a Jap warrior , so i cant remember the title . Even though the film is very crude it made me laugh…)
7. BLINDMAN
8. THEY CALL ME HALLELIUAH
9. FISTFUL OF LEAD
10. AND GOD SAID TO CAIN
11. MASSACRE TIME
12. CUTTHROATS 9
13. RETURN OF SABATA (for the Mario Bava lighting…)
14. PRICE OF POWER
15. 4 FOR THE APOCALYPSE (the Spaghetti on its last legs , Bret Hart is spinning in his grave…)
16. MATALO
17. KILL THE WICKEDS
18. TARGET FOR KILLING ( Tonino Valerii 1967)
19. CALIFORNIA
20. WHITE FANG ( Fulci )