Alternative Top 20


I replaced it with Tepepa (1969)

(david collins) #322

some of my all time favourites are not in the official top 20 anyway following the criteria this is my alternative top 20:

1, And God said to Cain
2, Prey for Vultures
3, Companeros
4, Vengeance
5, the Ruthless Four
6, the Moment to Kill
7, Johnny Hamlet
8, the Unholy Four
9, I am Sartana your Angel of Death
10, Specialist
11, Mannaja
12, Blindman
13, Django the Bastard
14, Tepepa
15, 10000 for a Massacre
16, God forgives, I dont
17, No room to Die
18, Massacre Time
19, Arizona Colt
20, Get Mean

(morgan) #323

Did you?

Well, I can always reconsider. All in all LO voglio morto is maybe a better film (by a strand of hair) than La Sfida dei MacKenna. But I like the latter more. You said it: very interesting …

(Asa) #324

Companeros is a Top 20 picture.

(david collins) #325

ooops well in that case move the rest up one place and add Kill the Wicked at number 20.

(Phil H) #326

Yes, this is a key point UglyOne427.
This should be a list of your 20 favourites that are not in the official top 20. Not your official top 20. The official top 20. Therefore if you love And God Said to Cain and The Bounty Killer then they should definitely be on your alternative top 20. To make it simpler, here is your post from the official top 20 thread. Everything I have highlighted in bold qualifies for your alternative top 20. Check it out and compile another alternative 20 list for me and I’ll add it in.

(Novecento) #327

I’ve gotta concur that “The Bounty Killer” and “And God said to Cain” are both really great and underrated!


Ok, here it goes

  1. Massacre Time (1966)
  2. One Silver Dollar (1965)
  3. Have a Good Funeral… Sartana will Pay (1970)
  4. Nest of Vipers (1968)
  5. Four Of the Apocalypse (1975)
  6. I am Sartana… Your Angel of Death (1969)
  7. Cut Throats Nine (1972)
  8. If you meet Sartana… Pray for Your Death (1968)
  9. Fort Yuma Gold (1966)
  10. The Tramplers (1965)
    10.And God Said to Cain (1969)
  11. Sabata (1969)
    12.The Grand Duel (1972)
  12. Arizona Colt (1966)
  13. Kill them All and come back alone (1968)
  14. Boot Hill (1969)
  15. Light the Fuse… Sartana is coming(1970)
  16. I am Sartana… Trade your pistols for a coffin (1970)
  17. Ace High(1968)
  18. The Unholy Four (1970)
  19. Requiescant (1967)

(Phil H) #329

That’s good, although you have 21 films here so I’ve left off the Deserter as it’s the last one.

I’ve also added all the others requested here and updated the page so it reflects the latest tally. Not much change really all bar one are the same films with a slight change in order. The newcomer is a switch of one Sartana for another with Parolini’s original making it onto the list now.

(JonathanCorbett) #330

There’s the poster for The Mercenary instead of Vengeance Is Mine and other two posters no longer appear, what happened?

(Phil H) #331

Sloppy formatting by me I suspect.
Hopefully fixed now


1.Gunfight at Red Sands
2.One Silver Dollar
3.Minnesota Clay
4.Gunmen of Rio Grande
5.Hole in the Forehead
6.May God Forgive You, but I Won’t
10.A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die
11.The Moment to Kill
12.Massacre Time
13.Vengeance is Mine
14.No Room to Die
15.Black Jack
16.I Want Him Dead
17.God in Heaven, Arizona on Earth
18.Kill them all, and Come Back Alive
19.The Tramplers
20.A Long Ride from Hell

(Phil H) #333

Am I right in thinking this is your first Alt Top 20 list Lone_Gringo?
Just making sure before I add it to the list.


“Yeah, sure Phil. Go ahead.”

(Phil H) #335

OK, added to my spreadsheet but I won’t be updating the page for a bit.

(The Man With a Name) #336

Mine keeps changing as I view more and more spaghetti westerns. I’m not going to submit mine until I feel satisfied.


This is my new alternative top 20 and I doubt I will be updating it anytime soon, but if I do update it, I will let you know.


Time to update my new alternative top 20

  1. Have a Good Funeral… Sartana Will Pay (1970)
  2. Four of the Apocalypse (1975)
  3. Five Man Army (1969)
  4. Massacre at Grand Canyon (1964)
  5. El Puro (1969)
  6. Nest of Vipers (1968)
  7. And God said to Cain (1969)
  8. Cut Throats Nine (1972)
  9. Grand Duel (1972)
  10. Unholy Four (1970)
  11. Adios Gringo (1965)
  12. Arizona Colt (1966)
  13. If you meet sartana pray for your death (1968)
  14. Kill them All and come back alone (1968)
  15. Boot Hill (1969)
  16. Light the Fuse… Sartana is coming (1970)
  17. Sonny and Jed (1972)
  18. Black Jack (1968)
  19. The Price of Power (1969)
  20. Fort Yuma Gold (1966)
  21. The Tramplers (1965)

(Phil H) #339

Happy to add your changes UglyOne427 and have now done so but I’m intrigued at the amount of differences between this and your last list which was such a short while ago. I count 7 drop outs including your top 2 from last time. Quite a change of heart.


Thanks. Their are still some films I haven’t seen that a lot of folks talk about. ( Face to Face, Bandidos, Death Sentence, The Specialists, A bullet for the general, Keoma, Blindman, Vengeance is Mine, Today its me, Tomorrow its you, Trinity is stil my name, Red Sun, Chino, Run Man Run) all of which I hope to get too by the end of the year. Up next on my vewing list are these:

These are what’s next on viewing list

  1. Duel In the Eclipse,
  2. May God Forgive You… I won’t,
  3. Wanted
  4. Keoma.
    5.they call him cemetery
  5. 7 dollars on the red
  6. the strangers gundown