Well here we go another thread to MALIGN SWs instead of praising
We are doing the job of the Anti SW detractors with these sort of threads
MY Candidates As "Top SW" That I DISLIKE or Rate As Mediocre are :
Duck You Sucker 1971 Rod Steiger.
It is more political then western, Poor plot , Not happy with Coburn /other cast NOT in My Top 200
My Name Is Nobody 1974 Henry Fonda
It is as other Terence Hill Comedies/Spoofs very unfunny, unecessary slapstick, has none of the qualities I love In a SW. NOT In MY Top 200.
The Great Silence 1968 Klaus Kinski.
It is very poorly cast (Trintignant/McGee) an even though Kinski is good, plot is gritty/realistic i just object to the Trintignant/McGee miscasting. In my Top 100 Sw Yes.
Maybe some others to be added later.
I am ASTOUNDED / OUTRAGED that technically PERFECT / CLASSIC SW MASTERPIECES :
FOR A FEW DOLLARS MORE 1965 CLINT EASTWOOD Lee Van Cleef
DEATH RIDES A HORSE 1968 LEE VAN CLEEF John Philip Law
That these 2 above For A Few $ 65 /Death Rides A horse 68 should be criticised/demeaned
It confirms my strong belief that these sort of "Worst SW" type threads are regrettable