Well here we go another thread to MALIGN SWs instead of praising :’(
We are doing the job of the Anti SW detractors with these sort of threads :’(
MY Candidates As “Top SW” That I DISLIKE or Rate As Mediocre are :
Duck You Sucker 1971 Rod Steiger.
It is more political then western, Poor plot , Not happy with Coburn /other cast NOT in My Top 200
My Name Is Nobody 1974 Henry Fonda
It is as other Terence Hill Comedies/Spoofs very unfunny, unecessary slapstick, has none of the qualities I love In a SW. NOT In MY Top 200.
The Great Silence 1968 Klaus Kinski.
It is very poorly cast (Trintignant/McGee) an even though Kinski is good, plot is gritty/realistic i just object to the Trintignant/McGee miscasting. In my Top 100 Sw Yes.
Maybe some others to be added later.
I am ASTOUNDED / OUTRAGED that technically PERFECT / CLASSIC SW MASTERPIECES :
FOR A FEW DOLLARS MORE 1965 CLINT EASTWOOD Lee Van Cleef
DEATH RIDES A HORSE 1968 LEE VAN CLEEF John Philip Law
That these 2 above For A Few $ 65 /Death Rides A horse 68 should be criticised/demeaned
It confirms my strong belief that these sort of “Worst SW” type threads are regrettable :’(