Vote for Our Official Top 20

Town Hall
641

[quote=“stanton, post:640, topic:190”]Muchas gracias

Oh, I’ve just seen, you’ve named The Grand Duel twice.[/quote]whoops! again duly amended. as a scarecrow once said " if i only had a brain".

642

A quick top-12:

  1. For a few dollars more
  2. For a fistful of dollars
  3. The good, the bad and the ugly
  4. The great silence
  5. Cut-throats 9
  6. Death rides a horse
  7. Day of anger
  8. Django
  9. The big gundown
  10. Companeros
  11. Once upon a time in the west
  12. A fistful of dynamite
643

[quote=“ION BRITTON, post:642, topic:190”]A quick top-12:

  1. For a few dollars more
  2. For a fistful of dollars
  3. The good, the bad and the ugly
  4. The great silence
  5. Cut-throats 9
  6. Death rides a horse
  7. Day of anger
  8. Django
  9. The big gundown
  10. Companeros
  11. Once upon a time in the west
  12. A fistful of dynamite[/quote]

Pleeeease,
if you have some more SWs you like, name 8 more to make it a top 20, a quick one, or a not so quick one (preferable).

Remember what Leone said: 12’s good, 20’s better

644

Must we post Leone movies individually? They take up so much space.
Note: FOD is nowhere near my top 30

1.Duck You Sucker
2.For A Few Dollars More
3.The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
4.Once Upon a Time In The West
5. Light the Fuse…Sartana is coming
6.Death Sentence
7.The Silent Stranger
8.Django
9.The Ruthless Four
10.A Pistol for Ringo
11. Cemetery Without Crosses
12. Massacre Time
13. Death Rides A Horse
14. The Mercenary
15. The Great Silence
16. God Forgives I Don’t
17. Keoma
18. Long Days of Vengeance
19. Duel in the Eclipse
20. The Grand Duel

645

Of course!!!

646

OK, although these lists tend to change quite often, here’s a top-20 of mine:

  1. For a few dollars more
  2. For a fistful of dollars
  3. The good, the bad and the ugly
  4. The great silence
  5. Cut-throats 9
  6. Death rides a horse
  7. Day of anger
  8. Django
  9. The big gundown
  10. Companeros
  11. Once upon a time in the west
  12. A fistful of dynamite
  13. If you meet Sartana…
  14. Blindman
  15. They call me Trinity
  16. Quien Sabe?
  17. God said to Cain
  18. Ringo Kill
  19. Sabata
  20. Mannaja
647

Gracias,
and you can change it of course whenever you like (if it’s not every day, which would drive me crazy).

Generally repeated for all contributors:
If you want to alter your list, and if you want to get it counted, it’s wiser to prepare a new one, instead of fumbling around with your old one (which maybe won’t be noticed by me).

648

Ringo Kill? Never heard of this title

649

It’s alternate title for “Night of the Serpent” [La Notte dei serpenti].

650

Oh yes, I remember now, the african DVD

651

I got an email today telling me that the last one in our top 20 page, is THE BEAST with 15 Points, and whether it is a typo and should be 1 point?

652

Ha ha, well observed. I’ve changed it.

I think I’ll make an update on sunday anyway, the world won’t be the same afterwards. So prepare.

653

OUATITW will finally kick GBU’s ass? hell yeah!

654

Does anyone think that the scoring list should be expanded to a top 40 or 50?
I’m sure most of the users here have seen at least 50 spaghettis & this would allow some of the more obscure titles a chance to get more points & get into the lower list.

655

No, no, not exactly, but, I fear, it’s more the other way round, it could possibly be the last time that OuTW is on #2!!! Holy shit, but there is still a trend that OuTW loses his once comfortable margin.
Gulp

And there’s at this moment a new # 20, after it seemed for a long time, that the 1st 20 were written in cement, and only changed positions amongst themselves.

Seems to be a global crisis … we can only hope that our great leaders will act in this troubled times with circumspection.

656

[quote=“Ming, post:654, topic:190”]Does anyone think that the scoring list should be expanded to a top 40 or 50?
I’m sure most of the users here have seen at least 50 spaghettis & this would allow some of the more obscure titles a chance to get more points & get into the lower list.[/quote]

There was and is an interest of some members in doing so, but it should be done outside this Top 20 thread, which purpose was and is to create a forum’s Top 20, which it does perfectly.

And it should be done imo only by members who have seen more than let’s say 200 (or 300?) Spagies. At this amount you have probably seen most, if not all, of the so called “better” ones, so that you can get an highly interesting ranking.

Question is how to do it without damaging our current Top 20 ranking?
And are there enough members who are willing to compile such an extensive list of 50 SWs?

657

Just give me a chance to send you my new Top 20

(The Mercenary will be in the Top 5 this time)

658

I will revise mine also, if you want to wait for that.

I will see if I can find a way to automate this whole thing. We’d have to compile a comprehensive list of let’s say about 100 films, that are ABC list, and put that to a poll of forum members, and then of that we chose the 20 who score highest. but it’d be hard to accomplish

659

[quote=“scherpschutter, post:657, topic:190”]Just give me a chance to send you my new Top 20

(The Mercenary will be in the Top 5 this time)[/quote]

I’ll wait, I’ll wait …

660

[quote=“Sebastian, post:658, topic:190”]I will revise mine also, if you want to wait for that.

I will see if I can find a way to automate this whole thing. We’d have to compile a comprehensive list of let’s say about 100 films, that are ABC list, and put that to a poll of forum members, and then of that we chose the 20 who score highest. but it’d be hard to accomplish[/quote]

Interesting idea.

Could be/should be combined with a list of all SWs.