Vote for Our Official Top 20

Town Hall
37

THINGS ARE GETTING COMPLICATED :stuck_out_tongue:

38

that’s a lot of fuss around something very simple.
can’t we work out a nomination and voting system just for in here? something simple? maybe we can come up with a list of 20 films IN NO ORDER? I think that would be easy, and we just run a vote on those we aren’t sure about or where we can’t agree. say, we all agree on 16 films, but 4 we just can’t figure out, so we take 10 films into a poll, and take the best 4 of those 10 to the rest of the 20, and we’re there: 20 of the best SWs. how does that sound?

39
  1. OUATITW
  2. Good, The Bad and The Ugly
  3. For a Few Dollars More
  4. Big Gundown
  5. My Name Is Nobody
  6. Death Rides a Horse
  7. Django
  8. Fistful of Dynamite / Duck You Sucker
  9. Great Silence
  10. Face to Face
  11. Day of Anger
  12. Keoma
  13. Forgotten Pistolero
  14. A Pistol for Ringo
  15. A Bullet for the General
  16. Run Man Run
  17. Navajo Joe
  18. Four of the Apocalypse
  19. Django Kill… If You Live Shoot
  20. Cemetery Without Crosses
40

Ok. If we want to just determine the best 20 in no particular order, we can do it like Sebastian suggested. You’ll get my list a bit later.

41

OK. I submitted 12 in no particular order earlier. Here’s another 8, again in no order:

  1. Companeros
  2. Django
  3. Death Rides A Horse
  4. The Stranger Returns
  5. Adios Sabata
  6. A Bullet For The General
  7. Blindman
  8. My Name Is Nobody
42

1 OUATITW
2 THE GREAT SILENCE
3 Leone’s DOLLARS trilogy: FOD, FFM, GBU
4 DJANGO
5 CUTTHROATS NINE: important to have a landmark Spanish western and this is it.
6 MANNAJA
7 BULLET FOR THE GENERAL
8 DJANGO KILL…
9 Sollima westerns
10 MASSACRE TIME
11 Garko Sartana films
12 KEOMA

43

My vote, in no particular order:

  1. For A Few Dollars More
  2. A Fistful of Dollars
  3. The Good, The bad, and the Ugly
  4. Django
  5. Massacre Time
  6. Texas, Adios
  7. The Big Gundown
  8. Run, Man, Run
  9. Great Silence
  10. Companeros
  11. Mannaja
  12. Sartana
  13. Have a Good Funeral my Friend, Sartana Will Pay
  14. Sabata
  15. Arizona Colt
  16. Bullet for the General
  17. Day of Anger
  18. Adios, Sabata
  19. Face to Face
  20. Bounty Killer
  21. Blood at Sundown
44

My favorite Spaghetti-Westerns are:

  1. “Il Mercenario”
  2. “Mannaja: A Man called Blade”
  3. “Tú perdonas . . . yo no” a.k.a “God forgives . . . I don’t”
  4. “The Quick and the Dead” (Does that count?)
  5. “My Name is Nobody”
  6. “Sabata”
  7. “The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly”
  8. “Fistful of Dollars”
  9. “Once upon a time in the West”
  10. “For a few Dollars more”
45

Cimitero senza croci anyone?

46

This is definetely one of the best.

47

how about we wait one more week (then my exams are over, haha) and then we assess and collect what we have and make a little vote about those 4 or 5 we can’t agree on… then we have something like a top-20 by about february 12 or so…

48

sounds ok to me.

49

Yea add Cemetery Without Crosses to my list. ;D

50

Here is my list. I merely have the same movie choice. Just added the last 4.
1 Good Bad Ugly
2 The Great Silence
3 Death Rides a Horse
4 Face to Face
5 Il Mercenario
6 Once upon a time in the west
7 For a few dollars more
8 For a fistful of dollars
9 Django
10 A Bullet for the General
11 Requiescant
12 Keoma
13 Big Gundown
14 Five men army
15 Django Kill
16 Fighting fists of Shanghai Joe
17 Red Sun

51

Here´s my list:

  1. Once Upon A Time In The West
  2. For A Few Dollars More
  3. The Good, The Bad And The Ugly
  4. The Big Gundown
  5. Face To Face
  6. The Great Silence
  7. A Pistol For Ringo
  8. The Mercenary
  9. If You Meet Sartana, Prey For Your Death
  10. Tepepa
  11. God Forgives, His Life Is Mine
  12. Django
  13. Fistfull Of Dollar
  14. Heads I Kill You, Tails Your Dead, They Call Me Hallelujah
  15. Companeros
  16. Trinity Is Still My Name
  17. Cemetery Without Crosses
  18. Matalo!
  19. They Call Me Trinity
  20. Sometimes Life Is Hard, Right Providence ?
52

hmm, is this really that good? I gotta get that dvd.

53

My Top Twenty!

  1. A Few Dollars More
  2. Good The Bad and the Ugly
  3. Great Silence
  4. Big Gundown
  5. Companeros
  6. Mannaja
  7. Beast
  8. Sabata
  9. A Bullet for the General
  10. Death Rides a Horse
  11. Blindman
  12. A Bullet For Sandoval
  13. Day of Anger
  14. Mercenary
  15. A Fistful of Dollars
  16. Price Of Death
  17. Navajo Joe
  18. Ramon the Mexican
  19. Price of Power
  20. A Fistful of Dynamite
54

WTF???

55

WTF! I didn’t know this was a stumper (La Belva) Klaus Kinski did great job as Crazy johnny the script was a bit weak, the music was great! They had a great idea with the whole sex crazed outlaw theme and still its enjoyable to watch. This was better than alot of crap people put on their lists. Terrance Hill is one of the worst actors. (P.S.) I didn’t bash Cemetary without Crosses because, I fell asleep watching it! I have a feeling you have not viewed too many spaghetti westerns to know what your talking about. When you graduate past all Terrance Hill, Leone, and Corbucci flicks come talk to me. Remember there are 558 Eurowesterns not (12) which you picked and could not even come up with 20. This shows how premature you are in this field.

56

Ok, ok. But personally I think La Belva is one of the worst spaghetti westerns I’ve seen. Kinksi is great as always and it’s funny to watch him trying to get laid all the time but the rest of this movie just sucks.

By the way, I just watched my 200th spaghetti western this week.