[quote=“Lindberg, post:1, topic:847”]There have been a few remakes of Sergio Leone’s first SW over the years, which of course was a remake of Kurosawa’s Yojimbo in the first place.
Anyway if you’re not already familiar with it, the Icelandic film Hrafninn Flygur from 1984 is at times almost scene for scene a remake of Fistful!
It’s about vikings in Iceland but the style and story is pure Leone Spaghetti-Western
It was a co-production between Iceland and Sweden, the Swedish title is Korpen Flyger, it also had an English title When the Raven Flies.
I’m not sure exactly in which countries it was shown though.
If you can find it it’s an interesting film to see, unfortunately I don’t have a copy of it at the moment.[/quote]
I’m glad to read about it here. I’ve seen it on Dutch (?) television, I suppose somewhere in the eighties , and didn’t remember the title. I’m pretty sure I saw it on television, and I guess it wasn’t released theatrically overhere, but I’m not sure.
It’s never mentioned when Fistful/Yojimbo are discussed, so from time to time I thought it was only a dream.
I remember I liked it very much, but I thought the ending was a bit different. There was something about a very young boy watching his father (?) getting killed. Or am I mixing things up?
[quote=“scherpschutter, post:2, topic:847”]I’m glad to read about it here…
It’s never mentioned when Fistful/Yojimbo are discussed…
I remember I liked it very much, but I thought the ending was a bit different. There was something about a very young boy watching his father (?) getting killed. Or am I mixing things up?[/quote]
Yes it’s an obscure film today I think, and it’s a pity perhaps, it’s not an absolute must-see, but interesting, obviously especially for fans of spaghettis.
You remember correctly scherpschutter, the ending is slightly different from Fistful.
The film’s Icelandic director Gunnlaugsson openly said that he was a big fan of Leone in particular and spaghetti-westerns in general, when the film premiered.
He did a couple of follow-ups to this film but they were not quite as influenced by Leone’s work.
You know when I saw the subject of this thread, at first I got mad… I thought you meant someone was actually remaking it.
So how would you all feel if some big Hollywood studio remade Fistful? I’d be piiiiiiisssssssed.
The sad thing is, it’s just the sort of thing Hollywood is likely to do.
I was checking my shelf and you can count the original stories released in the western genre in the last 20 years on your fingers and toes without taking your shoes off. Take out all the remakes and biopics (or pseudo biopics) and you are left with a pretty small group. No, original ideas are not a strong suit among todays movie execs when it comes to horse operas.
Regarding how I’d feel about a modern remake, I guess it depends how it was done. Being that Fistful itself was a remake of Yojimbo, its hard to argue that a remake of Fistful is any worse than the original- if enough originality is brought to the remake
If its just a typical Hollywood styled remake of an old movie, then that leaves plenty of room to be pissed about it… but honestly, right now I’d probably enjoy being able to go to the theatre to see something that is remotely interesting to me… I would still think its a shit idea, but I wouldn’t let that stop me from seeing/potentially enjoying it.
The spaghetti genre as a whole is nothing but remakes and stolen ideas. If someone was to remake it now, it wouldn’t really be any different than what the genre was doing, except for the fact its 30-40 years later…
Came across an article from Deadline that says a Fistful of Dollars remake is in the making from a company called Euro Gang Entertainment. Seems to be a team of american and italian producers with some creds.
I am not so comfortable with remakes, they usually don’t catch the same style as the original.
Don’t know how you can top the original with the style, action and music today. And most of all I fear to see this film getting “the modern audience” stamp.
How do you fellow gunslingers feel about this, do we need a remake?
its gonna suck, especially if they shoehorn in the modern day clown world crap like they usually do… there’s literally no point in remaking this film, it has aged like fine wine. It’s as great today as it was when it first released and you really can’t replicate the magic of Leone’s direction and the cast of the film.
What other reasons are there for studios to produce movies?
Plus, the “original” was already a remake. So after over 60 years, no matter where you stand on the idea of remakes in general (I dislike them, don’t get me wrong), the idea of a new take on the material isn’t entirely outrageous…
AFoD is too big of a classic, it should be left alone.