I’ve just got the Film Noir boxset. Having already seen “Gilda”, which one do you think I should watch first? (The films are: “In a Lonely Place”, “The Killers” and “Double Indemnity”).
The Killers and "Double Indemnity are both top notch I would watch one of those first.
Right, thanks for the advice.
Killers is great. Gonna buy the Criterion DVD myself
I’ve decided that I will go for “The Killers”, as I have heard only positive reviews of it (korano, foregive me if I’m wrong, thinks "Double Indemnity is overrated).
I have not seen Double Indemnity but I forgive you. Leaving the earlier stuff for later in my exploration of Noir.
If you are looking for some great Noirs, John, try Big Combo for one. But you’ve probably already seen it. Night of the Hunter is great, as is The Chase in some ways. Try also Amazing Mr.X. A little mix of horror and Noir
And off thetop of my head…:
The Good German
Odd Man Out
Crime Wave
Nightmare Alley
Night Has a Thousand Eyes
The Big Sleep
Act of Violence
Border Incident
Ride the Pink Horse
Hope you don’t think I’m being condesending to you forlisting. I know you are one of our Film Noirbuffs. 
Hope you don’t mind me adding a couple of humble recommendations…
The Sniper
The Unholy Four aka A Stranger Came Home
Blast of Silence
Private Hell 36
Where Danger Lives
Sorry about that. I must have got mixed up with someone else.
No need for apologies, guy.
Enjoy them anway
I’ll have to see this one, looks interesting… Edward G Robinson as well.
Check YouTube.
Not yet, but it’s going to be on IFC next week and i was going to check it out.
I don’t think i’ve ever said it here, but i think DOUBLE INDEMNITY is over-rated. It’s strikes me as good not great. Give me STRANGE LOVE OF MARTHA IVERS over DI anyday for a shot of Stanwyck being a bitch. IN A LONELY PLACE gets my vote for best movie in that set, but i don’t quite consider it noir.
Why not LonelyPlace? Always heard it was a defintive Noir
Doesn’t really have a protagonist of any sort. And i don’t remember the lights/shadows as being very noirish, but that could be a faulty memory.
But doesn’t that make it even more Noir?
Yes, if having less of the elements of noir makes it more noir for you. Then so be it. Don’t get me wrong, we’ve been playing fast and loose with the definition of noir throughout this thread, and that’s fine with me. At the end of the day, we all decide what is noir for ourselves. I just never thought of IN A LONELY PLACE as noir.
suit yourself amigo
Kinda’ the point. :
I have rewatched Arthur Penn’s Night Moves, a rather pessimistic noir film. In fact somehow one of these 70s anti-genre films which tried to take the genre from head to toes. This one is very precise, intelligent and still benefits from it’s human qualities.
The acting is superb, with the always great Gene Hackman at his best.
One of Penn’s best films. Not as spectacular as Bonny and Clyde and Little Big Man, but not less interesting.
Oh and it contains this great line about Eric Rohmer, which since no article about Rohmer fails to cite:
“I saw a Rohmer film once. It was kinda watchin’ paint dry.”